Once the Tables Turn

One debate is how often a cleric can turn undead. The DMG states that the cleric’s turn attempts are limited (p. 65, “As stated on the CLERICS AFFECTING UNDEAD TABLE, this function may be attempted only once by each cleric”). Clearly “may be attempted only once” doesn’t mean, “ever, in the lifetime of the cleric”, so the text must be examined for the limiter; it’s not purely “once”, nor “always”.

One might contend that turning is limited to once per encounter, requiring defining “what is an encounter”. Defining by encounter requires house ruling the exceptional cases. What if an encounter last longer than the turning effect of 3-12 rounds? What happens in the middle of the fight if more undead arrive (one encounter becoming two or more concurrent encounters?). What if the characters break away from the encounter (closing the door for example where skeletons won’t follow them), only to wait a few rounds, and reopen the door for a new encounter? While turning is discussed in the context of an encounter, nowhere does the text define the number of times a cleric can turn in the context of an encounter.

Once per encounter significantly nerfs the cleric’s turn ability against large groups of same-type undead (where large is groups greater than 12). Once per encounter doesn’t explain from a game perspective why a cleric can only keep turning the 100 skeletons only if there’s a zombie present (“Companion, raise a zombie so I can keep turning those skeletons we know are coming”). What well-intentioned necromancer would mix undead types?

I contend that the limit is once per individual undead, more specifically limited by failure to turn individual undead. If the cleric fails to turn undead, they can’t try again against those undead, but they can continue turning any remaining undead as long as they don’t fail. That’s supported by the text: “Any failure to turn undead disallows a further attempt by the same cleric” — failures limit attempts, successes do not.

That sentence is followed by, “Turning can occur at the same time as missile discharge, magical device attacks, and/or spell casting” and “It also is subject to initiative determination”, neither of which is relevant or specific to multiple forms (nor in need of clarification); instead further clarifications of the overall subject of turning undead. Looking at the entirety of the text: Turning undead “may be attempted only once by each cleric … Any failure to turn undead disallows a further attempt”.

The actual limiter of failure is consistent with other aspects of turn undead. When counter-affecting undead the cleric can keep counter-affecting undead “indefinitely until one or the other cleric fails and is no longer eligible to affect undead.” Clerics can re-turn undead that have returned after 3-12 rounds (“The turned undead will be able to come back again, but they are subject to further turning by the cleric.”) — those they have not failed against. Evil clerics can gain control of undead by not failing, the actual duration being defined by the level of their success. In the case of a “D”, they can repeatedly renew every 6 days, as long as they don’t fail. The limits for all of those are failure.

Success is defined as any case the cleric doesn’t explicitly fail. If a cleric attempts to turn a group of undead –single or multiple types– and fails, the cleric has failed against all of them (if he’d succeeded at all, he’d be determining which undead in the crowd were turned). “Failure to score the number shown, or greater, means the turning was unsuccessful.” If the cleric tries against a group, and succeeds, that’s not a failure even if some of the undead were not turned on a d12. The cleric hasn’t failed against the remaining undead yet (“Any failure to turn undead disallows a further attempt”), and could try again.

That then is consistent with the discussion of multiple types. Multiple types of undead create two cases that could cause exceptions to the base rules:
1) “what happens if the roll succeeds against one type, but fails against the other(s)?” If the cleric suceeds against any type, the net result is not a failure, and thus the cleric can try again, as long as he keeps turning something with each attempt, as he’s continued to not fail.
2) “what happens if the roll succeeds against all the multiple types”, which is clarified as they are turned “from the lowest HD first”.

There is the option presented to the DM of defining failure to instead be failure to turn all of them (must roll enough to turn the vampire to turn the ghasts and ghouls), making packs of undead more lethal, further supporting that the limit is failure.

Clerics can fail to turn undead once; until then they can try again. In the case of the exceptional case of multiple types, failure is clarified as failing to turn all types, not failure to turn some types.

One could choose to house rule “once” to additionally mean “fail once / encounter” or “fail once / day|week” or “once / level.” But it’s still … once.

Streamlining Cavalier Minions

Last Updated: 180815, 200616

The cavalier acquires followers and henchmen early and often. All told, there are 17 (!) different types of minions, with differing weapons, armor, armor class, hit points, and THAC0, making management a bit of a nightmare. At the same time, there’s a lot of flavor there, in particular in types of troop; it’s good to maintain at least the distinction between cavalry, infantry, and archers. Time to streamline that a bit.

Followers

The cavalier must go to a locale where such men-at-arms are located in order to attract these followers. Those followers lost are not replaced except by troops gained at higher levels. A cavalier’s followers will not demand wages or salary, but must be fed, cared for, and rewarded as suitable for the conditions. The number is not limited by Charisma.

By the Book Followers

01-50 Light cavalry in ring mail and shield, each with 3 javelins, long sword, and hand axe; or, Heavy infantry in scale mail, with pole arm of choice and club.

51-75 Heavy infantry in splint mail with morning star and hand axe; or, Heavy infantry in leather armor with pike and short sword.

76-90 Crossbowmen in chain mail with heavy crossbow and short sword; or, Crossbowmen in chain mail with light crossbow and military fork.

91-00 Cavalry in banded mail and shield with lance and horseman’s mace; or, Cavalry in studded leather with long sword and horseman’s flail. Either type will be mounted on medium warhorses.

Streamlined Followers

The streamlined minions have a higher than average THAC0, AC, damage, and hit points, to reflect their being a bit better than average.  For simplicity almost all of the damage dice and weapon speeds are the same.

  AC Average
50% 6 3
12.50% 4 0.5
12.50% 8 1
15% 5 0.75
5% 3 0.15
5% 7 0.35
    5.75

 

Average follower AC: 5.75, with bonus AC: 5

Cost: 10 gp / month each.

50% Heavy infantry in chain mail (AC: 5), with pole arm (d8, Weapon Speed: 8) and club (d8, Weapon speed 3). THAC0 19. 8 hp.
15% Crossbowmen in chain mail (AC: 5) with heavy crossbow (3d4, Weapon Speed: 8, Range 8/16/24), and short sword (d8, WS 3). THAC0 19. 8 hp.
35% Cavalry in scale mail and shield (AC: 5), with lance (d8, Weapon Speed 8), 3 javelins (d8, Range 2/4/6), and horseman’s mace (d8, Weapon Speed: 8), mounted on light warhorses. THAC019. 8 hp.

By The Book Leaders

For every group of 20 troops which serve a cavalier, there will be a fighter follower/leader of 5th level, dressed in plate mail and shield with a battle axe +2. For every 60 troops there will be a 6th-level fighter leader (with plate mail + 1 and shield, longsword + 2), and a 3rd-level fighter lieutenant (plate mail, battle axe).

Streamlined Leaders

For every 20 troops, there will be:

  • 5th level leader: AC 1 (Plate mail and shield), 35 HP, Weapon: d8 damage, weapon speed 6. +2 to hit, +2 damage, THAC0 15 Cost: 500 gp / month

For every 60 troops there will be:

  • A 6th-level leader: AC 1 (Plate mail and shield), 35 HP, Weapon: d8 damage, weapon speed 6. +2 to hit, +2 damage, THAC0 15. Cost: 600 gp / month
  • A 3rd level leader (similar to Esquire), for 300 gp / month.

Retainers (Henchmen)

Total number limited by Charisma +3

By the Book Retainers

As soon as a cavalier of good alignment reaches 4th level (Knight Errant), the cavalier must acquire at least one retainer. These retainers can be either Armigers (level l), or Scutifers (level 2), or both. Upon becoming a Knight (6th level), an Esquire (level 3) must be added to the staff. Upon becoming a Grand Knight (7th level), a Horseman (Level  0, d4+1 hp) to act as a herald and a Lancer (Level0, 2d4 +1 hP) to act as a guard must be added. At 8th level, the Banneret must bring at least an additional mounted man-at arms to his staff of retainers. All cavalier retainers will serve for nothing more than care, upkeep, and training, as applicable.

Streamlined Retainers

Retainers cost 100 gp / level / month

  • Level 1: (Horsemen, Lancer , Men-at-arms). Identical to Cavalry.
  • Level 2: (Armigers, Scutifers). Identical to Cavalry, except +1 to hit, +2 when mounted. 16 hp.
  • Level 3: (Esquire). Identical to Cavalry, except +1 to hit, +2 when mounted. 24 hp and THAC0 17.

The Lowly Thief-Acrobat

Last updated: 181231… 250621
ta@corwyn.net

The thief-acrobat is a mess. Most abilities are worse than an average high school athlete. In a world that mages can cast world-altering spells, even the best thief-acrobat can’t match a world record–ever. In a class where falling is key, they take more (relative) damage from a fall than a fighter with the same experience. The thief-acrobat should be better at thief-acrobat things than other classes. At the same time, the class should be distinct from thief and monk. Time to fix all that, while maintaining the spirit of the thief-acrobat. I started from the Dragon Errata articles, and moved on from there!

Any single-classed thief character with a minimum strength of 15 and a minimum dexterity of 16 may forego normal thievery and become a “split-class” specialist, a Thief-Acrobat.

Upon gaining sufficient experience points to achieve 6th level[2] as a thief, the character desiring to specialize as a thief-acrobat must seek out a thief-acrobat of at least 10th level to train him or her. It will require 6 full weeks of training to learn the basic skills needed to begin active practice of the social profession of thief-acrobat. Except as noted, the specialization procedure is otherwise the same as regular thief training.

A thief-acrobat may be of any race. Thief-acrobats with strength and dexterity scores of 16 or better add a 10% bonus to earned experience. Thief-acrobats gain six-sided hit dice up to 12th level, and 2 hit points per level after 12th (UA, Character Classes Table 1).

Weapons: As thief, plus lasso, staff, blow gun (DF).

Backstab is more villainous than carnival, and more similar to the other lost abilities.

The primary functions of a thief-acrobat are: tightrope walking, pole vaulting, jumping, and tumbling. In addition to these functions, the thief-acrobat retains the abilities to improve: move silently, hide in shadows, hear noise, climb walls, and read languages. This program of gymnastics precludes any further progress in the following skills: pick pockets, find/remove/set traps, open locks, and backstab. Ended skills max at 6th level (dexterity 16) to 9th level (dexterity 19) [2].  A thief-acrobat retains the ability to decipher magical writings and utilize scrolls at 10th level, just as regular thieves[2].

The thief-acrobat is only lightly encumbered when carrying up to 450 gp (increasing 10 gp per level > 6, and modified for Strength). A thief-acrobat cannot function beyond lightly encumbered. The exception is tightrope walking, where the limit is twice that of lightly encumbered.

Tightrope walking assumes that the character will use this means to cross from place to place. This skill allows ascent up a rope or beam up to a 45-degree angle or descent at a slightly steeper angle, all while upright and with hands free (in general). Movement is 60’ per round. If the distance is greater than 60’, then additional checks must be made for each additional 60′. A 6th level thief-acrobat has a 75% chance of success, improving 5% per level. Moderate winds decrease the chance of success by 10%, strong winds by 20%. In strong, gusty wind conditions there is always a 5% chance of failure. In non-windy conditions, a balance pole increases the chance of success by 10%. Failure means that the thief-acrobat falls, taking damage accordingly. Those characters who are not thief-acrobats can walk a tightrope at a base 20% chance, and move no faster than 30’ per round.

The world record for pole vaulting is 20′, in a world without magic, monks falling any distance, and in general heroes of old. Yet a 23rd level thief-acrobat can’t even tie that record? Average high school competitors can pole vault 12′. In a world when the thief can climb most obstacles, pole vaulting is of even less utility.

Pole vaulting includes any jumping which employs a leverage device to assist the individual in gaining height from momentum; e.g., a teeter board or springboard might serve as well or better than a pole in some cases. A successful pole vault requires at least a 30’ running start and a pole at least two-thirds the length of the distance to be vaulted. A 6th level thief-acrobat can pole vault 12′, increasing 2′ per level. The pole is dropped when the vault occurs. The vaulter can land on his or her feet atop a surface of 1′ less height than the maximum height of the pole vault if so desired, assuming such a surface exists. Otherwise, the vaulter lands, tumble rolls, and is on his or her feet in 2 segments[1]. The thief-acrobat cannot pole vault when engaged in melee. Non-thief-acrobats cannot pole vault.

So long as the thief-acrobat finds (or is able to place) a hanging object such as a rope, vine, or chandelier to use as an assist for at least half the distance to be covered, he or she may use the rope to swing up to a distance of up to twice the character’s maximum pole-vaulting height and land on his or her feet. (DF)

Jumping includes all sorts of unassisted leaps—high jumping and broad jumps (both from a standing and a running start).

All jumps assume the thief-acrobat will land on his or her feet. If the thief-acrobat wishes to leap in an extended position, 2′ of additional distance can be gained, but the character will land prone and take 2 segments to get back on their feet. A 3′ extension can be attempted, with a 25% chance of failure and a 3-segment period of recovery; a 4′ extension has a 50% chance of failure and an 4-segment recovery; an extension of 5′ has a 75% chance of failure and a 5-segment recovery period.

The high jump numbers aren’t horrible, but are rarely useful. But increasing by ¼” at a time?

High jumping requires at least a 20’ running start. At 6th level the thief-acrobat can high jump 4′, increasing 1′ per level. The high jumper clears the obstacle in a near-horizontal position but lands on his or her feet. If some elevated step, or a series of such steps, enables the character to maintain rapid motion, he or she can then high jump from such an elevated step just as if doing so normally. Alternately, the jumper can opt to land atop some higher surface. This surface must be 2’ under the maximum height for normal high jumping. In either case, the thief-acrobat lands on his or her feet in 1 segment. Non-thief-acrobats can high jump d4′.

For an average trained high school athlete a good broad jump is 8′. A good running long jump is 16′. The barbarian jumps 10’/16-21/4.5-6’ starting at level 1. And in a world measured by 5′ and 10′ increments, shorter distances aren’t that useful.

Broad jumping requires 1 segment to accomplish. A 6th level thief-acrobat can standing broad jump 8’+d4′ (increasing 1′ per level), and running broad jump 16′ + d4′, increasing 2’ per level. In standing jumps, the thief-acrobat can leap forward up to the maximum distance, or backward up to half the maximum distance, in order to attack or avoid being in attack range, if this is deemed possible by the DM. The thief-acrobat can therefore: attack and then broad jump out of attack range (after their opponent attacks); broad jump into attack range and attack (as charge); broad jump and backstab if their opponent is unaware of their presence. A running broad jump requires a run of at least 20′. A thief-acrobat executing a broad jump receives no AC Dexterity bonus.

Tumbling assumes all sorts of gymnastic skills—tumbles, rolls, jumps, handstands, and so on. These routines are then used in attack, defensive evasion, and in jumping/falling. Tumbling maneuvers have the following benefits:

The thief-acrobat can regain their feet in 1 segments.

The attack bonus needs to be enough to offset the fighter’s THAC0, if the intent is a TA being better than a fighter. The fighter’s THAC0 is ~5 better.

Attack improves the character’s Non-Weapon Score (NWS) in hand-to-hand combat involving Pummel, Overrun, or Escape. The 6th level thief has a 25% (+5) bonus, increasing 5% per level, to a maximum bonus of 50% (+10).

If the thief-acrobat wins initiative, Evasion enables the thief-acrobat to opt to avoid attacks directed at him or her (or attacks within a few square feet, from which the thief-acrobat could easily remove himself or herself) with respect to melee combat, missile fire, and (just as magic resistance would work) magical attack forms. The 6th level thief has a 10% chance of evasion, increasing 5% per level. In any event, the chance for success cannot exceed a base of 60%, before adjusting for dexterity and/or race. Evasion requires 1 segment, after which another action can be attempted.

Falling damage should be significantly reduced for a thief-acrobat. The monk has all the thief abilities of the thief-acrobat plus Open Locks and Find/Remove Traps, and still takes less damage from falling than the thief-acrobat. At 6th level the monk can also speak with animals, mask his mind, is immune to dead, and can feign death. Monks save for half or none without having to tumble, and can knock missiles out of the air, both skills more appropriate to the thief-acrobat. Before considering any 17+ Constitution bonus for fighters, a thief has only 63-75% of a fighter’s hit points. A fall that does 16 damage to a thief-acrobat does only 12 relative damage to a fighter. To make the thief-acrobat take the same relative damage as a fighter at a starting point the TA has to take only 66% of the damage; 33% to correspond to 50% of the damage a fighter would take. 50% equals the same result as calculating a fall as 10’ less. I prefer to keep the thief-acrobat distinct from monk, and instead improve and simplify the current thief-acrobat ability.

Falling damage for the thief-acrobat is a non-factorial d6 for each 10′ of damage, to a maximum of 10d6. At 6th level, a thief-acrobat can fall 10′ and take no damage; any fall is calculated as if the thief-acrobat fell 10′ less. This ability improves 10′ per level (e.g., an 8th level thief-acrobat could fall 30′ and take no damage; a 50′ fall would inflict 2d6 damage).

Climbing conforms to the thief ability. Rappelling adds 50% to climb walls if against a surface (30% if free falling).

Lassos are weird. They’re a weapon using THAC0, but if throwing a rope over a stalagmite, there’s a 20% chance of success? A difference in proficiency?

There’s a base 20% chance of success for a character to throw a rope over a projection (like a stalagmite) if not proficient. If proficient, the thief-acrobat can throw a lasso 1”/2”/3” at 6th level, increasing 5’ per level (max 60’), with a +4 bonus to hit, treating the stalagmite as AC0. d6 rounds to recoil.

A thief-acrobat can throw a grappling hook upward a distance equal to ⅓ their Strength score (×2 horizontally). A 6th level thief-acrobat succeeds on a base 45% (a +20% bonus), plus 5% per level above 6th (DSG).

In all other respects, the thief-acrobat is treated as a thief, including the gaining of followers, Thieves’ Cant, and guild membership.

  Tightrope

Pole Vault (30′ run) High jump (20’ run)2 Standing Broad2 Running Broad (20’ run)2 Evasion (%) NWS (%)
Non-T-A
(always extended)
20%
(30’/rnd)
– d4 1 + d4 5 + d4 – –
Non-T-A Level 7-9 – – +1’ +1’ +1’ – –
Base (level 6) 75%
(60’/rnd)
12’ 4’ 8 + d4 16 + d4 10 25
T-A per level > 6

 

+5% +2’ +1’ +1’ +2’ +5
max (60)
+5 (5%)
(max 50%)
Halfling/Gnome/Dwarf – -2’ -1’ -2’ -4’/-4’/-3’ +10/5/5 +5/10/10
Half-Elf/Elf/Half-Orc – – – – -/-1’/- +0/5/0 +5/0/0
Dex (16/17/18) +5/10/15 – – – – +2/3/5 +1/2/31
Extended (TA only)* – – – +2’/3’/4’/5’ +2’/3’/4’/5’ – –
No armor +5 +1’ +1’ +1’ +1’ +4% +2
Heavy/Very Heavy Enc. No No -1’/No -1/No -1’ No No

*Only the thief-acrobat can jump backwards or leap farther in an Extended position. Recovery is 2 segments/3 segments (25% failure)/4 segments (50% failure)/5 segments (75% failure).

1Already included in the Non-weapon Score (NWS)
2Those Encumbered cannot jump at all.

Bibliography

Unearthed Arcana. The Thief-acrobat.
A “split class” for nimble characters: The Thief-acrobat. Dragon Magazine Issue 69.
[2]Arcana update, Part 1. Repairs, reasons, and even more new rules. Dragon Magazine Issue 103. November, 1985.
Unearthed Arcana Errata. Dragon Magazine Issue 103. November, 1985.

Oops, I’ve Stolen Something

Last updated: 180808…250906
stolen@corwyn.net

Overview

PCs are left occasionally left with time on their hands. Mages & clerics research spells, fighters compete in the arena. The thief? Pick Pockets is a simple roll, but what would be the outcome? What if the thief wants to acquire more than a few coppers between adventures? Or the Guild makes a demand that can’t be refused? Theft within an “adventure” context requires one-on-one time with the player and DM, or extended downtime for other players while the thief role-plays the encounter that the DM had to create.

Borrowing from various resources, hewing closely to 1st Edition rules, I present here a system for Pick Pockets and Theft. Rules scattered far and wide are consolidated and streamlined, filling in gaps. Player decisions still affect outcomes. For critical life-or-death moments, tables provide granularity, but the generalities are treated, well, more generally.

Pick Pockets

Up to two pick pockets attempts can be made during a round. A successful Pick Pockets roll gains an item from the victim; the item is determined at random unless the exact location of a particular item is known by the thief.

The potential victim reduces the thief’s chances for success by 5% for every level of experience they are above the 3rd, i.e. –5% at 4th level, etc. Chances of success are also affected by the Category of the target: Simple (a lowly farmer), Difficult (a merchant, –10%), or Extraordinary (adventurer/nobility, –15%).

Pick Pockets fails if the player rolls above their chance to Pick Pockets. If the roll fails by 21% or greater, the victim notices the thief’s attempt (note the victim might notice yet allow the thief to operate in order to track them back to headquarters). Undiscovered failures allow additional attempts (twice / round).

Success

Once a pocket is successfully picked, roll 2d10, modified by Category (Simple +0, Difficult +8, Extraordinary +12):

2d10 Result
2 Lint
3 Parchment with a mundane note
4 A key
5 Lower class personal item (rabbit’s foot, needle, dice, playing cards, small knife, etc.) of no value
6 A small vial or flask
7 Coins (2d6 cp)
8 Coins (2d6 sp)
9 Gem (10 gp)
10 Lint
11 Parchment with a business note
12 A key
13 Middle class small personal item (rabbit’s foot, needle, dice, playing cards, small knife, etc.) worth d4 gp
14 A small vial or flask (1% chance DMG Table III.A Potions)
15 Coins (2d6 sp)
16 Coins (2d6 gp)
17 Gem (50 gp)
18 Small jewelry (wrought gold, 2d20 gp)
19-20 Lint
21 Parchment with official communication
22 A key
23 Upper class small personal item (rabbit’s foot, needle, dice, playing cards, small knife, etc.) worth d8 gp
24 A small vial or flask (5% chance DMG Table III.A Potions)
25 Coins (2d6 gp)
26 Coins (2d6 pp)
27 Small jewelry (silver with gems, d100 gp)
28 Roll twice on this table, ignoring results after this.
29 Trap
30 Roll again on this table. Appears successful, but something important was stolen and the target really wants their loot back. Mercenaries are hired to track the thief down.
31 Roll on Gem table, DMG p. 25
32 Roll on Jewelry Table, DMG p. 26

Pick Pockets Failure

The result of a known failure is adjusted for the Category (Simple +0, Difficult+2, Extraordinary +4).

d10 Result
1 Chased. Lose d6 CON from exhaustion. Roll Evasion or lose d6 hp (cannot be fatal) and CON recovers one point per day of rest.
2 Beaten up—lose d6 hit points unless armored.
3 City Guard. Bribe way out with d100 gp or Arrested.
4 Chased. Lose d6 DEX. Roll Evasion or be injured for 2d6 hp (cannot be fatal). DEX recovers one point per day of rest.
5 Beaten up—lose 3d6 hit points unless armored.
6 Chased. Lose d6 STR. Roll Evasion or lose 3d6 hp (none in armor, non-fatal). STR recovers one point per day of rest.
7 City Guard. Arrested. If a guild member, the Thieves’ Guild will arrange bail for 2d100 gp, expecting the money back at 100% interest.
8 Beaten up and robbed—lose 5d6 hit points (none in armor, non-fatal), plus anything vaguely useful or valuable is taken.
9 Grabbed by a crowd of locals and punished: 1. pilloried, 2. tarred and feathered, 3. stripped naked & chased.
10 Word of ineptitude reaches Thieves’ Guild. Lose guild membership. If not a member of the guild beaten for 2d6 damage, increasing d6 for each offense.
11 Trapped. Explosive dye, a man-trap just right for prying hands.
12 City Guard. Can kill guard to attempt Evasion.
13 Steal a cursed item.
14 Killed (Save vs. Death to escape).

Burglary

A thief with access to civilization may perform solo burglary missions—the Heist!

Theory

Three different “By The Book” foundations exist for determining the success of a heist:

  • Assassins’ Table for Assassinations (DMG, p. 75)
  • Assassin Spying Table (DMG, p. 18)
  • The Thief Functions (PHB, p. 28)

The Assassination Table relies on a single roll, taking into account the level of the victim, which could be used to determine reward vs. difficulty, but burglary is more like spying than assassination. A Spy succeeds based on two Spying Table rolls (counting Discovery). Thieves could use different Thief Functions if performing a heist through roleplay, which has a certain appeal, as those abilities adjust based on character level, class, race, and Dexterity. The Thief Functions can also be modified by magical items (such as Boots of Elvenkind affecting Move Silently). However, exercising multiple thief functions during a typical heist (requiring individual rolls for each Thief Function) almost guarantees failure. Perhaps an average of those combined values? Pick Pockets would be excluded, given its clear use for a different task. Hear Noise and Read Languages are outliers from a success perspective, leaving five abilities: Open Locks, Finding Traps, Moving Silently, Hiding in Shadows, and Climbing Walls. That generates an Averaged Thief Function, which lends itself to a rounded/simplified composite of the thief and assassin abilities:

Thief Level Averaged Thief Functions (Rounded) Assassin Spying Table
Simple Difficult Extraordinary
1 31% 50% 30% 10%
2 35% 55% 35% 15%
3 39% 60% 35% 15%
4 44% 65% 40% 20%
5 49% 70% 45% 25%
6 54% 75% 50% 25%
7 59% 80% 55% 30%
8 64% 85% 60% 35%
9 69% 85% 60% 40%
10 74% 90% 65% 45%

The averaged chance of success across all the Thief Functions are all similar to the Difficult Assassin Spying Table tasks, varying no more than +9%. Using the existing Thief Functions to determine success hews closer to 1e than directly using the Assassination Table or creating yet another table. Averaged Thief Functions are the baseline of Heist success.

The more difficult the job, the higher the reward for success but also the higher the penalty for failure? Incorporating the Assassin table, heists would be separated into the Simple, Difficult, and Extraordinary.

How long does it take for a successful heist, when taking into account preparation and execution? Casing the joint is easier and shorter than a spying mission, and the odds of being discovered are less than a spying mission, so the difficulty categories should be adjusted downward from a time and discovery perspective.

Thief Function Modifiers

What about the invisible PC? A halfling? Wearing Boots of Elvenkind? Using a Chime of Opening? With a high Dexterity? Flying? The Averaged score combines five different Thief Functions (Open Locks, Finding Traps, Moving Silently, Hiding in Shadows, and Climbing Walls), suggesting a methodology to modify the overall chance of success—adjust the base Thief Functions percentages to modify the overall chance of success if one determines any delta to the individual Thief Function, and adjusts the overall chance of success by the delta divided by 5 (to represent the overall change across the five Thief Functions). Using this general methodology, the DM can readily (and less arbitrarily) determine modifications to the chance of success based on player specifics. Two adjustments to the same Thief Function might or might not be considered additive. Any one Thief Function shouldn’t adjust over 95%. Let’s look at some examples:

  • A halfling is 10% better at Moving Silently, which would increase the overall chance of success by 2% (10%, divided by the five Thief Functions).
  • If a 5th level thief (Move Silently 40%) were wearing Boots of Elvenkind (95%), his ability to Move Silently is effectively 95% (a 55% increase), increasing his overall chance by 11% (55%, divided by the five Thief Functions).
  • If an 8th level thief were invisible, his Hide in Shadows ability could increase from 49% to 95% (note the 95% maximum), an increase of 46% improvement in Hide in Shadows, or a 9% increase to his overall chance of success.
  • A Chime of Opening for a 5th level thief? 42% Open Locks to 95%, but –25% from Move Silently for the time(s) the Chime is used, so and 11% –5% modifier.

PC Characteristics

The effects of Race and Ability score modifiers can also be pre-calculated using the existing tables for race and ability:

Race Heist Modifier
Dwarf +3% +10% Open Locks, +15% Find Traps, -10% Climb Walls
Elf +2% -5% Open Locks, +5% Move Silently, +10% Hide in Shadows,
Gnome +2% +5% Open Locks, +10% Find Traps, +5% Move Silently, +5% Hide in Shadows, -15% Climb Walls
Half-Elf +1% +5% Hide in Shadows
Halfling +4% +5% Open Locks, +5% Find Traps, +10% Move Silently, +15% Hide in Shadows, -15% Climb Walls
Half-Orc +4% +5% Open Locks, +5% Find Traps, +5% Climb Walls

 

Dexterity Score Heist Modifier (No dexterity bonuses apply when wearing armor other than simple leather)
16 +1% +5% Open Locks
17 +4% +10% Open Locks, +5% Move Silently, +5% Hide in Shadows
18 +8% +15% Open Locks, +5% Find Traps, +10% Move Silently, +10% Hide in Shadows
19 +12% +20% Open Locks, +10% Find Traps, +12% Move Silently, +12% Hide in Shadows

Armor

Armor Heist Modifier
None +5% +10% Move Silently, +5% Hide in Shadows, +10% Climb Walls

 

A thief wearing no armor gains a +5% Heist Modifier (from the associated Unearthed Arcana: +10% Move Silently, +5% Hide in Shadows, +10% Climb Walls, which could affect adjustments from other sources). However, the thief is now at greater risk in any encounters if things go wrong, as they’re no longer wearing armor!

Thieves’ Guild

The thief can increase their chance of success, and make the fencing of stolen goods easier, as a member of the Thieves’ Guild, for a percentage to the Thieves’ Guild. The initiation fee for the Thieves’ Guild costs 1,000 gp (± 500 based on city size, ±500 based on approved theft difficulty). A Thieves’ Guild will require a 15% cut of any crimes committed.

Membership in the Thieves’ Guild increases the chance of any success by 5d4%.

There is a 20% chance that the Thieves’ Guild will become aware of the crime if the thief is not a member.

Chance of Discovery

It takes time to execute a successful heist: making discreet inquiries; identifying a target; casing the joint; waiting for the right moment (moonless night, appropriate distraction, owner out of town); leaving no trace behind. The Base Chance to be Discovered is a cumulative 1% per day spent preparing (subject to a maximum of 10%), minus the level of the thief, to a minimum of 1%. The probability of discovery depends on the Category of the heist:

Heist Category Time to Prepare Probability of Discovery
Simple  1 to 8 days  1%, checked each week
Difficult  3 to 24 days  Base Chance%, checked each week
Extraordinary  5 to 40 days  Base Chance%, checked twice per week

Sometimes, the thief is in a hurry! Decrease the chance of Heist Success by 1% for each day the thief needed to prepare, and doesn’t!

Frequency

Repeated heists in a short time will put town citizens on alert! Each successive heist attempted within an identical period (i.e., d8 days from the last Simple heist) will decrease the chance of success by d10%.

Chance of discovery will increase tenfold if a thief is discovered and another heist is attempted during a period of 20 to 50 days thereafter. If the heist is discovered, go to the Heist Failure Table below.

Results

Once all modifiers have been tabulated, the DM checks the Heist Chance for Success to determine Success or Failure. 5% or less will always fail, and even success won’t always mean getting away scot-free!

Example

We have a 9th level (69%) dwarven (3%) thief with a 19 Dexterity (+12%) who isn’t wearing armor (+5%). They’re attempting a simple heist with no preparation (-d8%) where they rolled a 7:

69% + 3% + 12% + 5% – 7% = 82%.

Before they set out, a MU casts Invisibility on them, increasing their Hide in Shadows from 56% to 95% (an increase of 39% divided by the five Thief Functions, or +8%).

Before he sets out, a friendly cleric casts Silence 15′ Radius on him, increasing his Move Silently from 70% to 95% (an increase of 25% divided by the five Thief functions, or 5%). However the Silence will only last 18 rounds in this case, where the Heist will take an hour, so the DM grants only a 2% bonus.

Totaling a 92% chance of success, almost as good as the 95% maximum permits!

Treasure

The Treasure Category Multiplier matches the crime: Simple (200 gp), Difficult (1,000 gp, +10% to roll), Extraordinary (5,000 gp, +20% to roll)

d100 Treasure Details
1-21 Nothing of Value
22-45 Coins d6 * Category Modifier gp in various coins.1 Note coin weight!
46-60 Gems d6 * Category Modifier gp in various gems. See DMG, p.25, Treasure Type Q (×[n])
61-70 Jewelry d6 * Category Modifier gp in various jewelry. See DMG, p. 26
71-80 Gems and Jewelry d6 * Category Modifier gp in gems and jewelry or Treasure Type R. See DMG, p. 26-27.
81-90 Rare Commodities d6 * Category Modifier gp. See DMG, p. 27.
91-95 Antiquities d6 * Category Modifier gp value.
96-98 Religious Icon d6 * Category Modifier gp value.
99-100 Potions Simple (1 potion), Difficult (d3 potions), Extraordinary (d6 potions) or Treasure Type S.
101-105 Scroll(s) Simple (1 spell, lvl 1-3), Difficult (d3 spells, lvl 2-5), Extraordinary (d6 spells, lvl 3-7) or Treasure Type T.
106-119 Roll Twice on this Table Can roll more than once, less than this.
120 The Motherload Treasure Type I (gems, jewelry, magic).

Coin distribution varies on Category: Simple (20%sp/30%ep/50%gp), Difficult (30%ep/55%gp/15%pp), and Extraordinary (80%gp/20%pp). Multiply % * (value in gp), then adjust for value of coins (i.e., gp value * 20 for # of silver).

Heist Success!

Should the thief succeed, roll to determine the results.

Heist Results Modifiers:

Results Modifiers Results Roll Modifier
Difficult +10
Extraordinary +20

Heist Results

Heist Results Table
d100 Type of Result
≤01-10 Success
11-15 Wild success (roll again on the Treasure Table)
16-35 Partial success (Flight, acquiring only 10%-90% of the Treasure value)
36-65 Success
66-80 Quality success (+25% on Treasure Table)
81-85 Trapped (Walk Away or make Remove Traps check to succeed). See DMG Appendix G. (d6: 1-2 Damage, 3-4 Poison Type A-C, 5-6 Lethal)
86-90 Poisoned (requires Save vs. Poison): Type A 15 hp damage (Simple), Type B 25 hp damage (Difficult), Type C 35 hp damage (Extraordinary). Chance to notice poison: A:80%/B:65%/C:40%*
91-95 Poisoned (requires Save vs. Poison or die): Type D.  Chance to notice poison 15%*
96-100 Apparent success, but if Bribery was used during the heist, they squeal to the Watch after the heist. Arrested. Otherwise no effect.
101-105 Apparent success, but Thieves’ Guild discovers afterwards of unsanctioned heist (if not member of Thieves’ Guild). Check Encounter Reactions for their response. Hostile responses: Fine equal to 2x value of heist, Quest, Expulsion. Otherwise no effect.
106-110 Apparent success, but your target wants their loot back. Mercenaries are hired to track thief down. Captain level 1-3 (Simple), 4-7 (Difficult), 9-12 (Extraordinary)
111-114 Apparent success, but Thieves’ Guild discovers afterwards of unsanctioned heist (if not member of Thieves’ Guild). Check Encounter Reactions for their response. Hostile responses: Fine equal to 2x value of heist, Quest, Expulsion, Death. Otherwise no effect.
115-117 Apparent success, but an Invisible Stalker is summoned to return the stolen goods.
≥117-120 Apparent success, but precious item stolen, creating a powerful enemy who will pursue the PC.

*If the thief notices the poison, they can roll a Saving Throw or safely abandon the heist.

Disposition of Goods

Turning rare or unusual goods into cash creates its own problem. Anything besides coin requires a fence! Without specific proficiencies, the thief’s appraisal of the stolen goods can vary by 10%-200%. Finding a fence will take d4 * (1:Simple, 2:Difficult, 3:Extraordinary) days. When first meeting a fence, determine the Fence’s reaction:

Modifiers (cumulative):

Modifiers to Fence Reaction
+10 Thieves’ Guild Membership
-10 Difficult
-20 Extraordinary
+5 Charisma 13
+10 Charisma 14
+15 Charisma 15
+25 Charisma 16
+30 Charisma 17
+35 Charisma 18

 

Disposition of Goods Table
d100 Fence Reaction
<01-15 Double-cross (only if value > 5,000 gp). Steals item(s) and escapes (otherwise makes Initial Offer).
16-23 Outraged. Makes Initial Offer but contacts authorities unless member of Thieves’ Guild.
24-29 Fence refuses to deal in commodity. Arrested unless member of Thieves’ Guild.
30-35 Fearful. Fence refuses to deal in commodity.
36-41 Cannot afford goods at this time. Try again in d4 weeks.
42-47 Concerned. Offers reduced by ½.
48-59 Neutral. Makes Initial Offer. Will demand bribe (d6 × 100 gp) for silence if refused.
60-67 Intrigued. Raises maximum offer by (5 × d6)%.
68-83 Neutral. Makes Initial Offer.
84-100 Must Have It. Offers 75% of actual value.

The fence will start with the Initial Offer. The thief can negotiate with another roll on the Disposition of Goods Table. The fence will increase the offer by d20% actual value until failure, agreement or the maximum is reached. There is a 10% chance after each offer that the fence will refuse to do business further.

Initial offer: 10% + 5% × d4 of the actual value
Maximum Offer: 15% + 5% × d12 of the actual value

Experience

A thief receives XP equal to 1/10th the value of goods stolen. This is modified by multipliers for the degree of heist difficulty: Simple (× ½), Difficult (× 1), or Extraordinary (× 1½).

Heist Failure

If a thief fails their Heist Chance of Success roll, it’s time to determine just how awry things have gone. Heist Failures are spread out within the table based on a base change of being Killed (5%), Proof (15%), Escape (25%), Suspicion (20%), and Discovery (chances > 100%).

Failure Modifiers:

Heist Category Failure Roll Modifier
Difficult -5
Extraordinary -10
Discovered +20

 

Heist Failure Table
d100   Failure Result
≤01 Killed (5%) Killed (Save vs. Death if wearing armor).
02-06 Proof (15%) Arrested with the Goods! See Crime and Punishment.
07-11 Proof (15%) Arrested with the Goods! Kill City Guard to attempt Evasion.
12-16 Proof (15%) Attacked with the Goods! 4d6 damage (halved in armor). Arrested or attempt Evasion.
17-21 Proof (15%) Arrested with the Goods! (d4 × ½ Treasure Category Multiplier) gp to bribe way out of it.
22-41 Escape 25% Barely Escaped. Further Attempts during Category Preparation Interval are 90% Likely to Fail.
42-46 5% Nighttime City Encounter (See DMG, Appendix C). Check Encounter Reaction* when appropriate.
47-75 Failure (35%) Failure. There are many possible causes for basic failure: a lock could not be picked, residents arrived home unexpectedly, left tools at home, etc.
76-80 Suspicious (20%) Tricked (see DMG, Appendix H).
81-85 Suspicious (20%) Caught during heist. Arrested for Trespass.
86-90 Suspicious (20%) Triggered alarm! Arrested for Trespass. Roll Evasion to Escape.
91-95 5% Underestimated Difficulty (and Reward). Roll entire Attempt again adjusting Category up one step.
96-100 Suspicious (20%) Triggered alarm! Arrested for Trespass. Roll Evasion at -40% to Escape
101-104 Discovery > 100% Discovered by Watch entering building. Check Encounter Reaction* to determine arrest for Trespassing.
105-108 Discovery > 100% Thieves’ Guild learned of unsanctioned heist (if not member). Check Encounter Reaction* for their response. Hostile responses: Fine equal to value of planned heist, Quest, Expulsion. Otherwise no effect.
109-112 Discovery > 100% If Bribery was used during the heist, they squeal to the Watch before the Heist. Check Encounter Reaction to avoid Arrest.
113-116 Discovery > 100% Queried by the City Watch. Check Encounter Reaction* to avoid arrest for Trespass.
117-120 Discovery > 100% Observed. Check Encounter Reaction* for whether they report it. Successful Disguise prevents Arrest.

 

Adjusted Result (d100) Encounter Reaction
≤01-05 Violently hostile, immediate attack
06-36 Hostile, immediate action
37-64 Neutral—uninterested / uncertain
65-95 Friendly, immediate action
96-00 (or greater) Enthusiastically friendly, immediate acceptance

*Any intelligent creature conversed with will react in some way to the character that is speaking. Reaction is determined by rolling percentile dice, adjusting the score for the Charisma Reaction Adjustment, and comparing to the table below:

Charisma Reaction Adjustment
13 +5
14 +10
15 +15
16 +25
17 +30
18 +35

Crime and Punishment

A thief arrested will be charged and tried. Fines and jail time are cumulative. Repeat offenders receive stiffer sentences within the Punishment category. The third (and subsequent) conviction always results in the maximum sentence.

Charges
Crime Type  
Trespassing (Simple, Difficult) Class 1
Trespassing (Extraordinary) Class 2
Unarmed Assault Class 1 Fists or threatening harm
Armed Assault – Lesser Class 2 Improvised weapons (club, bar stool)
Armed Assault – Greater Class 4 Deadly weapons or magic
Theft of Goods ≤ 10 gp Class 1
Theft of Goods 11 gp to 100 gp Class 2
Theft of Goods 101 gp to 1,000 gp Class 3
Theft of Goods 1,001 gp to 10,000 gp Class 4
Theft of Goods > 10,000 gp Class 5
Using Magic ? An additional charge of the associated crime Type
Forgery ? An additional charge of the associated crime Type
Escape/Flight Class 3 Fleeing the Authorities to escape the consequences of a Crime
Trial

Once arrested, a trial takes place within d6 weeks. The Judge can be bribed with a successful Bribery check (and payment equal to half the fine). Membership in the Thieves Guild will increase the bribery chance by 25%. A failed Bribery check will negatively affect the outcome and always include jail time.

Trial Modifiers Trial Outcome Adjustment
Bribery ±10
Difficult Crime +10
Extraordinary Crime +20
Charisma 13 -5
Charisma 14 -10
Charisma 15 -15
Charisma 16 -25
Charisma 17 -30
Charisma 18 -35

 

d100 Trial Outcome
<1-30 Acquittal
31-50 Default Punishment (Fine if applicable)
51-65 Default Punishment (Prison if applicable)
66-75 Default Punishment (Both Fine and Prison if applicable)
76-95 Third conviction, or Class 4 and above: Mutilation. Otherwise Fine and Prison. Sentence carried out in d4 days.
96-100+ Third conviction for Class 4 and above: Death. Otherwise Fine and Prison. Sentence carried out in d6 days.

 

Type of Crime Punishment
Class 1 Fine: 1d6 gp OR Jail: 1 Day OR Both
Class 2 Fine: 10d6 gp OR Jail: d6 Weeks OR Both
Class 3 Fine: 100d6 gp OR Jail: d6 Months OR Both
Class 4 Fine: 1,000d6 gp OR Jail: 1 Year OR Both
Class 5 Fine: 5,000d6 gp OR Jail: d6 Years OR Both
Class 6 Fine: 10,000 d6 gp OR Jail: 5d6 Years OR Both OR Death
Class 7 Death

Crime and Punishment Tables can be adjusted based on the severity of punishment with a particular culture.

The Attempt

  1. The thief (or DM) decides the Heist Category: Simple, Difficult, Extraordinary
  2. Gear up! Calculate the modified Heist Chance of Success (based on stats, magic, race, Dexterity, etc.)
  3. Determine time required to execute the heist
  4. The DM determines the value of the loot, modified by the Heist Category
  5. The DM determines if thief is Discovered (If a thief is discovered, roll on the Theft Failure table)
  6. The PC rolls to determine their Heist Success or Failure
    1. The DM determines the results
  7. The PC decides on the disposition of goods acquired
  8. Check whether the Thieves’ Guild becomes aware (20%) if the thief is not a member

Proficiencies

Below are few examples of relevant proficiencies.

Appraisal

This skill allows the character to make generally accurate (±10%) assessments of common objects, including items made of precious metals and gemstones. The character can also assess, to ±25%, the value of objects of art, tapestries, furniture, weapons, etc., provided a variety of these items are present in the game world. These assessments require no proficiency checks and the DM can roll (d20 or d100) to determine the accuracy of the appraisal.

A character who passes a proficiency check will be able to identify a forgery of a valuable object, to make a very accurate assessment of the value of a common item (within 5%), or to make a general assessment of the worth of an uncommon item, including artifacts. The DM may wish to roll this check, and on a roll of 20 the character makes a wildly inaccurate assessment. Intelligence, 0 penalty.

Bribery

Successful Bribery includes understanding the appropriate target, the timing of the offer, the amount most likely to generate the desired reaction, whether the one receiving the bribe will keep his side of the bargain, and the best way to avoid drawing attention from witnesses. Bribery allows the thief to judge (75%) how much of a bribe is required. A successful proficiency check (or rolling under half of their Charisma score) will increase one Thief Function by 25% (generally improving the chance of Heist success by 5%). Failure indicates the bribe is inadequate or refused and makes the chance for success correspondingly more difficult. The character may be reported to the Watch (depending on the Encounter Reaction). Charisma, 0 Penalty.

The cost of a Bribe will vary depending on the Heist: Simple (d10 gp), Difficult (d10 gp × 3), Extraordinary (d10 × 10 gp). More than one Bribe can be attempted.

Disguise

Characters trained in Disguise can conceal their appearance through makeup and costuming. They can make themselves look like any general type of person of about the same height, age, weight, and race. A successful proficiency check indicates that the disguise is successful, while a failed roll means the attempt was too obvious in some way. If the task is more difficult—the character in disguise meets and talks with an acquaintance, for example—an additional proficiency check is required. A successful disguise will prevent follow-up from an Escape or being turned in.

Characters altering their sex, race, or size, must make successful proficiency checks with a –2 penalty for each category. Character may attempt to disguise themselves as a specific person, with a –10 penalty to the proficiency check. These modifiers are cumulative, thus, it is extremely difficult to disguise oneself as a specific person of another race or sex. Charisma, –6 penalty.

Forgery

This proficiency indicates a skill at creating false documents, mimicking the handwriting of others, and detecting forgeries. To forge a document (military orders, local decrees, etc.) where the handwriting is not specific to a person, the character needs only to have seen a similar document before. To forge a name, an autograph of that person is needed, and a proficiency check with a –2 penalty must be successfully rolled. To forge a longer document written in the hand of some particular person, a large sample of his handwriting is needed, with a –3 penalty to the check.

If the check succeeds, the work will pass examination by all except those intimately familiar with that handwriting or by those with the Forgery proficiency who examine the document carefully. If the check is failed, the forgery is detectable to anyone familiar with the type of document or handwriting—if they examine the document closely. If the die roll is a 20, the forgery is immediately detectable to anyone who normally handles such documents without close examination. It is important to note that the forger always thinks he has been successful; the DM rolls the character’s proficiency check in secret and the forger does not learn of a failure until it is too late. Dexterity, –1 penalty.

PCs caught after using Forgery on Extraordinary crimes add Forgery to their charges.

Ruse

Ruses are oddities to create distractions, such as hiring mourners to fake a funeral procession outside to benefit his Hide in Shadows approach, or poisoning the guard dogs’ meat so their reactions are sluggish for the Move Silently check. Like Bribery, the player selects a specific Thief Function to improve. A failed Ruse puts the guards on alert instead, decreasing the Thief Function value by the same amount.

The cost of a Ruse will vary depending on the difficulty of the Heist: Simple (d10 gp), Difficult (d10 × 3 gp), Extraordinary (d10 × 10 gp). Only one Ruse may be attempted per Heist. Intelligence, –2 Penalty.

Bibliography

TSR 2010, Players Handbook [1e], 1978. [Pick Pockets]
TSR 2011, Dungeon Masters Guide [1e], 1979. [Spying, Pick Pockets]
Thieves’ Guild: The Fantasy System. Gamelords, Ltd. 1984. [legal system]
TSR 9193, GAZ 1: The Grand Duchy of Karameikos [BECMI], 1987. [crime, Thieves’ Guild]
Dragon Magazine Issue 47, Leomund’s Tiny Hut: The Thief: A Special Look, March 1981.
Dragon Magazine Issue 104, Was it Worth the Risk: A DM’s Guide to Pick Pocketing Success, December 1985.
Polyhedron Issue 41, Arcana Academy: Adding to the Thief, May, 1988. [Infiltrate, Appraise, Streetwise, Ransack]
TSR 2114, The Castle Guide [2e], 1990. [bribery]
TSR 1071, Rules Cyclopedia [BECMI], 1991.
TSR 2010, Player’s Handbook [2e], 1995. [forgery, disguise]
TSR 2154, Player’s Option: Skills and Powers [2e], 1995. [forgery, appraisal, disguise]
TSR 2445, Defilers and Preservers: The Wizards of Athas [2e],  1996. [bribery]
Footprints Issue #2, What Have I Got in my Pocket? August 2004.
http://the-city-of-iron.blogspot.com/2011/11/pick-pockets-results-charts.html

Appendix A: Converted Spy Failure Table (Reference Only)

Dice Score Result
01-35 Failure. There are many possible causes for basic failure: a lock could not be picked, residents arrived home unexpectedly, left tools at home, etc.
36-60 Alerted! Burglary attempt against same target will be 90% likely to result in failure, discovery, and imprisonment.
61-80 Arrested for trespassing.
81-95 Caught with the goods and arrested for burglary (and trespassing). Value of the goods determines punishment.
96-00 Arrested for evading capture and either destruction of property or resisting arrest (on top of burglary and trespassing). Value of goods determines punishment.

 

Spellcasting Mobility

Last Updated: 170901,…200608

A campaign with a dedication to the spell, Fly, can be very different. PCs who Fly add literally a 3rd dimension to the game. That dynamic extends beyond basic movement considerations to the specifics of casting spells while flying. So what restrictions are on spellcasting while flying? When not flying? In short (for those who don’t care about the why):

  • Spellcasters cannot cast spells unless stationary for the entire round. Exception: Flying characters can cast spells when moving slowly (<3″)
  • Spellcasters cannot cast spells when carrying someone (flying or otherwise)
  • Spellcasters cannot cast spells when being carried (flying or otherwise)

In short, spellcasters cannot cast spells when limited or restricted physically.

Spellcasters cannot cast spells when carrying someone, as casting is not possible when hindered:

  • PHB, p. 100: “Physical restraint, including grappling, grasping, binding, etc. prevents proper somatic spell completion, for gestures must be exact and movements free and as prescribed.”
  • DMG: “The somatic portion of a spell must be begun and completed without interruption in a clean, smooth motion. Spells cannot be cast while violently moving – such as running, dodging a blow, or even walking normally … Thus casting a spell requires that the figure be relatively motionless and concentrating on the effort during the entire course of uninterrupted casting … the caster cannot be crouching, let along prone, during casting. … a mere shove at any time can spoil the dweomer.”

Further insight comes from spellcasters’ inability to cast spells while walking, even though they CAN marginally cast spells while flying (“most spells can be cast when Flying while hovering or moving slowly (defined as 3”)). If the PC must be standing, and when not flying can’t be moving, then the whole body must be involved in the somatic casting process. Flying must mean the PC can move (slowly) but still gesture with your legs, since the legs are not involved in locomotion.

PCs can’t cast spells when riding a flying mount, or when on a Broom of Flying. Even a magic carpet, “the most stable of flying devices,” only permits casting when “hovering or moving slowly,” and a magic carpet is significantly more stable than being carried by someone else.

That begs the question of when is casting not possible in general for a normal caster? If a character has a backpack of gear? Certainly possible. If they have a backpack full of halfling? The right answer is to integrate encumbrance (which includes “bulkiness”) into the consideration of “hindering.” Encumbrance can be broken into (two different ways, great editing TSR):

  • None: Nothing of real import.
  • Normal (Light): carrying 35# of gear with no great bulk.
  • Heavy (Moderate): Armor and equipment up to about 70# or fairly bulky.
  • Very Heavy (Heavy): Armor and equipment of 105# and/or bulky
  • Encumbered (Severe): up to 150# and/or very bulky.

Extrapolating from encumbrance, given that some the multi-class PCs (Fighter/Magic-user) can cast spells in plate armor with backpack (45# + 40#), casting has to be possible into Very Heavy/Heavy category. Casting would only be restricted in the “Encumbered/Severe” category (which includes almost all cases of carrying someone), as the PC is too encumbered to be able to cast spells in a “clean, smooth motion.”

In the context of the Fly spell, I define lifting limits of Fly to that which a character can carry (150# from Appendix O, modified by Strength). Since a halfling weighing 60 lbs. can carry the same amount as a Barbarian weighing 300 lbs, average Strength (not size) is pegged to being able to lift 150#. While a character with an 18/00 Strength would be able to lift/carry 450# when flying, they still would be unable to cast spells (because of the limitations defining freedom of movement).

For the most extreme of cases, the character with an 18/00 Strength would (in most cases) be able to carry another PC, but that carried PC cannot cast spells while being carried.

There’s a reason why physical limitations on spellcasting are important. In a world where spellcasters cast spells with few physical restrictions, they become high-risk captives; the best solution would be to kill them and be done with it. Even if mages couldn’t cast spells when gagged, the risks would be too great. If tying them up (or restricting their movement) prevents them from casting spells, holding mages as captives becomes a more viable alternative.

What’s Special about Alchemy

Last updated: 170513…201006

(This article has been supplanted by The Alchemy of Potions)

Potions may be made by any magic-user of 7th level or above, if he or she enlists the aid of an alchemist (q.v.). At levels above the 11th, such assistance is no longer mandatory, although it will reduce the amount of money and time the player character must spend making the potion by 50% of the compounding/infusing time normally required [above 11th level], as the alchemist will be so employed instead.

As PCs reach 7th level magic use, they approach the ability to create potions.  For my campaigns, most of the questions of item construction typically resolve by the party never having quite enough time to get anything done but leveling, but I still should understand how that works!

Until 12th level, PCs need to hire an alchemist to create potions. In the DMG, hiring an alchemist as an Expert Hireling requires hiring them for at least a year, and building a lab for them (200 gp to 1,000 gp + 10%/month maintenance). But what if the PCs just want to hire an alchemist short-term to work with their magic-user?

The Alchemist

The alchemist’s base rate of 300 gp/month is a good place to start for the costs of an independent contractor alchemist. A modern baseline for hiring a professional is at an hourly rate that is twice their normal salaried rate (where expenses are included in that rate). Our alchemist costs 300 gp/month salaried, which would be 600 gp/month as a contractor. Assuming a four-week month, and not counting potion materials, the alchemist will cost 150 gp / week or about 25 gp /day (and our average alchemist works on a weekly rate for any measurement in weeks, and a daily rate for work calculated in days).

If the alchemist is running his own lab, then the cost of the overhead on that lab needs to be reviewed when evaluating the cost of hiring him. “In order to begin manufacture of a potion (… made only one at a time), the magic-user must have a proper laboratory … [which] would cost between 200 and 1,000 gp … upkeep of the laboratory requires a further monthly outlay of 10% of the total cost of the place.” An alchemist’s lab, per Player’s Option: Spells and Magic (S&M), costs 65 gp/month rental for the floor space.  The 10% maintenance (to stock basic fuel and supplies, replace broken equipment, and so on) averages to another 60 gp/month. Average operating costs for an alchemist are 65 gp (rental) + 60 gp (maintenance), or 125 gp /month, 21% of his hourly rate, close enough to the operating expenses of an independent contractor to help validate the math.

The Formula

The DMG (p. 116) states that the cost and days for determining the formula for a potion is based on the experience point award of the potion, where each hundred xp (or fraction thereof) indicates 100 gp  and one full day of time to manufacture the liquid, i.e., 250 xp = 250 gp basic costs and 3 full days of time. The cost and number of days required to brew the potion once in possession of a formula uses the same figures. Contextually the suggestion is the cost for a PC. But what about hiring an alchemist, who needs to make a profit?

To hire an alchemist, a potion formula costs the XP value of the potion in gp (materials) + 150 gp/week (salary). The xp range of potions varies from 200 xp-1000 xp. Weighting the potion experience point values and costs by frequency, the average potion in the DMG is 367 xp or an average cost of 4 days: 400 gp (materials) + 100 gp (salary). But creation of the formula shouldn’t be guaranteed. Using S&M the chance of success is 6, with a -3 penalty, or 15%. Failure requires an additional full week (400 gp + 150 gp). It will on average take four tries to create a formula (.85×.85×.85×.85), making the average formula “value” of the average potion 2,150 gp (500 + 550 × 3). After the formula has been developed, it would not have to be researched again.

The Potion

The cost of creating potions is partially defined in the DMG:

“Both the cost in gold pieces and the days of compounding and infusing are determined by use of the xp award amounts. The xp for a given potion is the amount of gold pieces the magic-user must pay in order to concoct the [initial] basic formula (default to 200 gp). Each hundred or fraction thereof indicates one full day of compounding time to manufacture the liquid, i.e., 250 xp = 250 gp basic costs and 3 full days of time. Most important to the manufacture of a potion is the substance of its power, the special ingredient.”

While defining the basic cost of creating a potion, the DMG does not define the cost of the most important component—the special ingredient. While the obvious solution is that the adventurers gather the special ingredient(s) themselves, there’s the obvious correlation of the gold piece value of a potion and the special ingredient(s) required to construct it. There’s no ready way to figure that out with the data so far—let’s put a pin in that cost for the moment.

The DMG suggests a failure rate of 5%-20% can be assigned to all potion manufacture (resulting in a potion of delusion), but how to know exactly what chance a failure to assign?   S&M defines the chance of success with a formula as 70% + 2% / character level, -1% for each 100 gp of the cost. The character in question creating the potion is a minimum of 7th level, so an average 80% change of success is reasonable, which corresponds with the DMG’s 20% chance of failure plus an additional 2% chance of success for each PC level over 7th, -1% for each 100 gp of the potion cost as listed in the DMG.

What happens when upon failure to create a potion? The DMG suggests that these failures could be the source of the potion of delusion, but that’s uninteresting. The Potion Miscibility Table provides some guidance, and can be readily adapted if the wording is changed a bit (See also White Box: Men & Magic):

 

Dice Score Result

01 EXPLOSION! Those in a 10’ radius take 4-24 hit points, no save.
02-03 A poison gas cloud of 10’ diameter; all within it must save versus poison or die.
04-08 Mild poison which causes nausea and loss of 1 point each of strength and dexterity for 5-20 rounds, no saving throw possible.
09-15 Potion totally destroyed.
16-25 Potion ruined (potion of delusion).
26-35 Potion at 50% normal efficacy.
36-90 Ruined.
91-99 Potion has 150% normal efficacy (You must determine if both effect and duration are permissible, or if only the duration should be extended.)
100 DISCOVERY! The potion’s special formula will cause its effects will be permanent upon the imbiber with harmful side effects.

Weighting the potion xp values and costs by frequency, the average potion in the DMG is 367 xp, with an average gp value/sale price of 924 gp. Producing that average potion will cost 367 gp (materials) + 100 gp (alchemist, 4 days), for a net average profit of 457 gp, or 49%!  However, a few costs are as yet unaccounted for: we haven’t paid for the special ingredient; there’s a ~20% failure rate when creating potions; we haven’t included anything to represent the initial cost of creating the formula in the first place.

In summary so far:

Average cost to research potion formula: 367 xp for 4 weeks @ 100 gp / week (materials) + 150 gp/week (alchemist), with a 15% success rate, average 2150 gp and 5 weeks (technically 3 weeks and 4 days).

Cost to create potion:  For each 100 xp, 1 day and 100 gp (materials) + 25 gp/day (alchemist), average 467 gp.

Chance of failure: 20%, modified by 2% for each level over 7th, -1% for each 100 xp.

To figure out the value of the formula of the potion, I’m going to amortize the initial expense against the cost of creating the formula over a year. For our average potion, each attempt would take 4 days. Our alchemist can’t take time off in the middle of creating a potion, so if working 6 days a week in a 52-week year, our intrepid creator can only produce 1/week for 52 weeks. Taking into account the ~20% failure rate, 42 successful potions would be created in a year. If we amortize the cost of the formula creation over a year’s production (the life of adventurers and alchemists is short), the expense of 2,150 gp to create the formula amortized over the profits of those 42 potions available for sale is 51 gp/potion.

Assuming a 5% return on the investment, the cost formula becomes (assuming the 20% failure rate):

(Sales Price * 4) – ((Formula Cost + Material Cost + Alchemist Cost + Special Ingredient Cost) * 5) = 5% (Formula Cost + Material Cost + Alchemist Cost + Special Ingredient Cost)

OR

(924*4) – (51 + 367 + 100 + Special Ingredient)*5 = .5% * (51 + 367 + 100 + Special Ingredient)
3696 – (518+Special Ingredient)*5 = .05* (518 + Special Ingredient)

20*3692 – 100(518 + Special) = 518 + Special

73840 – 100(518 + Special) = 518 + Special

73322 – 100*(518 + Special) = Special

73322 – 51800 – ( 100 × Special )  = Special

21522 – (100 × Special )= Special

22522  = 101 Special

Special Ingredient = 223 gp

223 gp is 24% of the potion’s average sale price of 924 gp, providing an average value of the special ingredient (or ingredients) purchased in any potion created: 24% of the sale price (average 231 gp).

The ingredient cost can be used to determine the street value of potion components were the party to get into the business of selling potion components. Assuming a 50% markup before being purchased by a wholesaler selling alchemical components, an average potion’s raw special component(s) is worth roughly 152 gp.

Final results for creating a potion, with the help of an alchemist in his lab:

Average Cost to research formula: 4 weeks @ 100 gp / week (materials) + 150 gp/week (alchemist), average 2,150 gp.

Cost to create potion, assuming a 5% profit margin for the alchemist who created the potion: xp value in gold + 24% of the sale price of the potion (special ingredient) + 25 gp/day (alchemist). Takes 1 day / each 100 xp of potion, average cost 688 gp.

Chance of failure for each potion: 20%, + 2% for each level over 7th level, -1% for each 100 xp.

Other math, such as how much are the costs if the PCs create the formula, or provide their own ingredients, should be readily calculable using the above assumptions.

Extending that data to components required for other magic items, a baseline of ~24% of the cost of magic item creation is the materials.

Appendix

It’s also worth noting that Dragon #130 has an extended article on the Alchemist class, which divides the potions into “levels” for a different method of determining the cost of the potion formula. The article includes other suggestions, such as: an expanded list of special ingredients for particular potions; a different Failure Table; a much higher rate of potion creation (one level of potion/day per alchemist level); and limiting the level of potion creation by the level of alchemist.

Previous versions of the Alchemist class are included in Dragon issues #2, 45, and 49. Dragon #2 (1976, D&D) also ranks the potions by level and a methodology to determining time and cost to produce. Dragon #45 suggests a detailed methodology for potion identification. Dragon #49 lists various ways failed potions could adversely affect the user, and also suggests that substituting special components with an increased rate of failure.

Dragon #2, 1976 (D&D)
Lists potions by level of difficulty to create.
Potions require 200 gp + 1 week/level of potion to produce.
Research costs are the same as that for a MU researching spells.
40% more likely to create a potion formula with an example.
Lists potions by level, and several new potions.

Dragon #45, January 1981
Specialist alchemists.
Monthly salary of 30-120 gp + 10,000 gp for the lab.
Potion identification costs 100-150 gp/day, identifying potions at xp/100 hours) with ~95% accuracy.

Dragon #49, May 1981
Lists potions by difficulty to create.
Alchemists as a spell-casting class.
Substituting ingredients increases chance of failure.

Dragon #130, Feb., 1988. “Better Living Through Alchemy. Poison and Potions: The alchemist NPC class”
Lists potion special ingredients

Player’s Option:  Skills & Powers, 1995.
Alchemist

Player’s Option: Spells & Magic, 1996.

Population

Last Updated:  170401…200704

I use Mystara as the basis of my campaign world. Overall population of the Grand Duchy is about 621,400 people, including 537,800 humans, 41,900 demi-humans, 36,050 humanoids, and 5,650 other creatures (taking into account only the races who are represented by not less than 100 members in the country). When the PCs seek assistance (such as finding a cleric of high enough level to cast Raise Dead), how many people in the Kingdom are leveled characters to aid them?

Using the framework provided by the DMG, on average 1 in 100 of the human (and half-orc) general population are suitable for level advancement (other races have an incidence of 1 in 50). The base NPC population is defined as 44% Fighter, 20% Cleric, 20% MU, 15% Thief, and 1% Monk, or:
35.2% Fighters
17% Clerics
17% Magic-users
12.5% Thieves
4.4% Paladins
4.4% Rangers
3% Druids
3% Illusionists
2.5% Assassins
1% Monks

Assuming a baseline 600,000 pop, 1 in 100 is leveled, or 6,000 people have levels in the kingdom. Assuming level ratios roughly match experience points (XP), the number at each level would halve, so:

3,000 are level 1
1,500 are level 2
750 are level 3
375 are level 4
188 are level 5
94 are level 6
47 are level 7
24 are level 8
12 are level 9
6 are level 10
3 are level 11
2 are level 12
1 are level 13

Reversing that math, for our 600,000 population:
1 in 200 are level 1
1 in 400 are level 2
1 in 800 are level 3
1 in 1,600 are level 4
1 in 3,200 are level 5
1 in 6,400 are level 6
1 in 12,800 are level 7
1 in 25,000 are level 8
1 in 50,000 are level 9
1 in 100,000 are level 10
1 in 200,000 are level 11
1 in 400,000 are level 12
1 in 800,000 are level 13 (Note of our 600,000 population)

Out of 6,000 leveled people:

2,640 fighters, (264 rangers, 264 paladins)
1,200 clerics (200 druids)
1,200 magic users (200 illusionists)
900 thieves (150 assassins)
60 monks

So there are 94 people (approximately 100) in all of Karameikos that are level 6:

44 fighters (including 4 rangers and 4 paladins)
20 clerics (of which 3 are druids)
20 magic users (of which 3 are illusionists)
15 Thieves (of which there are 2 assassins)
1 Monk

If factoring in the actual class XP tables instead of just level, you get a slightly different ratio (although it doesn’t start to change until 3rd level, and doesn’t change much after that). Taking into account the XP tables, for the approximately 100 people in Karameikos that are level 6:

43 fighters (5 rangers and 5 paladins included)
20 clerics (of which 4 are druids)
20 magic users (of which 4 are illusionists)
15 Thieves (of which there are 3 assassins)
1 Monk

So the level 9 cleric the party is seeking? Well, there are 12 level 9 NPCs (and they aren’t all necessarily good guys!):

3.17 level 9 fighters
1.53 level 9 clerics
1.53  level 9 magic users
1.125 level 9 thieves
.4 level 9 paladins
.4 level 9 rangers
.27 level 9 druids
.27 level 9 illusionists
.225 level 9 assassins
.09 level 9 monks

The numbers above for 1 in 100 are for leveled characters in general, and aren’t quite right at the higher levels (not enough monks and druids, for example). Most of those leveled NPCs will be in a situation where they are currently satisfied with their lot in life. When considering henchmen, on average only 1 in 10 of those leveled NPCs are interested in offers of employment. In areas of active adventuring, that could be as favorable as 1 in 2. In a settled and staid area that incidence could be as low as 1 in 50.

These population numbers normally shouldn’t include those that are actively adventuring (which would include the PCs). Those of high level would, likely, concentrate in cities except for those who are reclusive (clerics in town, MUs out of town except where there’s a school or something, for example).

House Rules

I have yet to encounter (or even hear of) a group that plays with zero house rules. House rules can be many things: attempts to clarify existing rules, attempts to create rules to fill in gaps, or changes to rules that just don’t work. As with every group, our house rules attempt to address all three. Of the most importance is consistency; I started a House Rules document to ensure that the universe the players functioned in resulted in the same answers every time. Whenever we answer a complex question, we make sure to write it down. That saves looking it all back up again at a later date!

Hit points are a combination of the ability to take physical damage, and the more ephemeral ability to avoid damage. For years we used a slightly more complex system dividing hit points up into those two components, defined as “Body” and “Skill”. The character had the same number of hit points, just divided between the two categories. Body was the character’s Constitution. Skill was, well, everything else. By default all damage started at Skill; once all Skill points were gone damage went to Body. Blows that hit by greater than 5 went directly to Body.

I really liked this system. It provided the ability to damage a character with many hit points by applying damage directly to the Body. Characters could heal Skill points much faster than Body, so daily healing could be much faster if characters were only wounded into Skill. Yet every time the party rested, there was always some level of confused player discussion, and I eventually (with regret) retired it as unworkable.

A number of our house rules are just inclusions of obscure rules, or clarifications of gaps in the rules. When trying to find answers to those questions, I default back to earlier editions and Dragon Magazine before resorting to answers in later editions.

I come from a background of twenty years of full-contact armored combat (the SCA), so I tend to view combat very tactically. As players are wont to move about in combat, we eventually adopted a hybrid of the 2e initiative system. Each player rolls a d10, and then adds whatever bonuses (or penalties) to their initiative. Characters act in order of their initiative. The secret sauce to that is that actions take place in sequence. If a fighter rolls an 8, then wants to move half their movement (+4), then all movement occurs at 13. If a spellcaster is casting a spell through the area the fighter is moving through, we know that the fighter is in that area between 9 and 13. If the spell goes off in that interval, the fighter could be affected. If the spell goes off before 9, then the fighter will be unaffected. [Edit: We eventually shifted to a more “all-or-none” approach for AoE spells as faster-see Initiative Modifiers].

All of the spell-casting classes are provided the ability to flex their spell casting to make the spell-casters more adaptable. Magic users can swap two “memorized” spells (or a spell one level higher) for a single, different spell. Clerics can swap any spell for a necromantic (healing) spell. Druids can memorize twice as many spells as normal, but only cast the same number they could usually cast. Clerics memorize more interesting spells than healing, but have healing available if necessary (more often than not!). Magic users get usage out of those obscure spells that previously no one ever memorized on the off-chance it might be necessary, normally preferring “standard” spells of more utility.

There is no edition of Dungeons & Dragons that has a good non-weapon/hand-to-hand combat system. We attempted for years to come up with a system that dealt appropriately with combatant level, armor class, and number of opponents, before finally settling into the system we use now. It’s an opposed system, where each combatant rolls dice and compared the results for success. The system uses THAC0, primarily defining success based on character class and level. We now use this opposed system for all sorts of things, like breaking through an enemy line, or disarming.

We don’t normally pay a lot of attention to encumbrance, trying to just use common sense. We have some players that are very detail-oriented, tracking the weight of every spike, and other players who just want to play. After a long session determining just how much treasure the party could haul out of a particularly lucrative lair, we needed something in the middle. I created a generic encumbrance system for the less-detail-oriented players. Those players who go to the effort of tracking everything get a slight advantage, because the generic system assumes a bit more weight than normal, but a small enough difference to leave everyone happy.

House Rules (revised)