Oops, I’m Assassinating

Last updated: 231215..250111
as@corwyn.net

While assassins are rare in most campaigns, the question that comes up is how to assassinate someone? (while getting your web page probably flagged by the FBI)

 At the simplest level, if an assassin surprises someone, they can attempt to assassinate:

PHB, p. 29: However, if they [the assassin] surprise (q.v.) a victim, they may attack on the ASSASSINATION TABLE. This gives a roughly 50% chance of immediately killing the victim; and if this fails, normal damage according to weapon type and strength ability modifiers still accrues to the victim. Thus, if a poisoned weapon is used, the victim must also make the saving throw versus poison or die. The assassin decides which attack mode he or she will use: assassination, back stabbing, or normal melee combat.

Simple enoughif the assassin has surprise, they can choose to assassinate using the ASSASSINATION TABLE. The assassin can use any weapon, and a shield, but like the thief is limited to performing class-functions to leather armor.  Yet nothing in AD&D is ever simple. Can the assassin use ranged weapons? While missile weapons are never specified as excluded, the fact that the choice of assassination is included as an alternative to “normal melee combat” speaks to assassination itself being only possible with non-missile weapons.

However, assassination isn’t always simple. In the DMG:

The percentage shown is that for success (instant death) under near optimum conditions. You may adjust slightly upwards for perfect conditions (absolute trust, asleep and unguarded, very drunk and unguarded, etc.). Similarly, you must deduct points if the intended victim is wary, takes precautions, and/or is guarded. If the assassination is being attempted by or in behalf of a player character a complete plan of how the deed is to be done should be prepared by the player involved, and the precautions, if any, of the target character should be compared against the plan.

For the assassin, spying missions are defined as: Simple, Difficult, and Extraordinary. The scenario where the assassin surprises someone and attempts to assassinate them is described as “simple”:

Therefore, if an 8th level assassin snuck up on and surprised a 10th level magic-user in the dungeon and successfully assassinated him, the assassin would receive 1,000 x.p. plus another 100 x.p. since the magic-user was 2 levels higher than he. However, since it was a simple mission, the total 1100 x.p. would be multiplied by %, giving 550 points.

However, there’s another way for an assassin to function—developing an assassination plan and submitting it to the DM. If the assassination is being attempted by or in behalf of a player character a complete plan of how the deed is to be done should be prepared the player involved, and the precautions, if any, of the target character should be compared against the plan. You can see that reflected in the section on poison as well:

He or she can then use poisons at full normal effect and have the following options as well:

  • choose to assassinate by an instantaneous poison
  • elect to use a slow acting poison which will not begin to affect the victim for 1-4 hours after digestion
  • elect to use a poison which gradually builds up after repeated doses victim for 1-4 hours after ingestion and kills 1-10 days after the final dose

… This does not guarantee the assassin success, naturally, for he or she must still manage the poisoning and then escape.

Certainly not a scenario including Surprise!

The DM then determines any adjustment to the roll on the ASSASSINATION TABLE

The ASSASSINATION table should also be used when any character class is making an attack on a helpless (e.g., sleeping) opponent (DMG, p. 70, 75).

References

TSR 2010, Players Handbook [1e], 1978.
TSR 2011, Dungeon Masters Guide [1e], 1979.
Polyhedron #22, “In the Black Hours”, Volume 5, Number 1, 1984, p. 17: “The three assassins move silently and invisibly toward the Crown room by different routes, dispatching any guards they meet along the way by assassination if they have complete surprise, otherwise by backstabbing”

Oops They’re Creating Magic Items

Last Updated: 240616…250605
fabrication@corwyn.net

Of the many rules one would expect to be complex and incomplete, those for creating (and recharging) items are surprisingly thorough, if a bit scattered. Here they are, integrated, including clarifications from Dragon magazine and Wilderness Survival Guide. See Potion Creation and Alchemy  for  specifics on potion creation.

A character must be at least an 11th level high priest, a 13th level druid, a 12th level wizard or an 11th level illusionist in order to manufacture magic items (except with respect to potions and scrolls).

Potions may be made by any magic-user of 7th level or above, if he or she enlists the aid of an alchemist (q.v.). At levels above the 11th, such assistance is no longer mandatory, although it will reduce the amount of money and time the player character must spend making the potion by 50% of the compounding/infusing time normally required, as the alchemist will be so employed instead.

Scrolls may be inscribed only by characters of 7th or higher level, and the spells placed upon the scroll must be of a level which the inscribing character is able to employ, i.e. a 9th level magic-user could not place a 7th level spell on a scroll.

Fabrication

When creating (or charging) a magic item, all spells must be cast from memory—scrolls or magic devices can never be used to enchant an item or cast magic upon an object so prepared.

Magic Users

Most magic items that are not potions or scrolls can be created by a magic user of 12th level and above. Specifics for the item, the spells, and the material components must be determined, either by research, consulting a sage or discovering instructions in a long-forgotten tome.

The item: 1) must be in sound and undamaged condition; 2) must be crafted of the highest quality material with the finest workmanship; and 3) must cost or reflect a value reflecting the second test, and in most cases the item must have a raw materials cost in excess of 100 gp (*typically at least 24% of the sale value listed in the DMG).

Except for clerical items (created by clerics), potions and scrolls, magic items require the spell enchant an item to prepare the item for further enchantment. The material component(s) for enchant an item vary according to the nature of the item being magicked and the successive magicks. For example, a cloak of displacement might also require the hides of 1 or more displacer beasts, a sword meant to slay dragons could require the blood and some other part of the appropriate type(s) of dragon(s), and a ring of shooting stars might require pieces of meteorites and the horn of a ki-rin. (*Again, typically the spell components will be at least 24% of the sale value listed in the DMG).

Once the process, item, and material components are acquired, the casting of enchant an item can begin. All work must be uninterrupted. The item must be continually touched by the spell caster during the casting of enchant an item, a casting time of 2 + 1-8 (d8) days. During rest periods absolutely no other form of magic may be performed, and the magic-user must remain quiet and in isolation. Even during rest periods the item must never be more than 1’ distant from the magic-user, for if it is, the whole process is spoiled and must be begun again.

The magic-user will “know” when the casting of enchant an item is complete and the item is ready for further enchantment. They then pronounce the final magical syllable, and, if the item makes a saving throw versus magic (the same as the magic-user, including any saving throw bonuses, not exceeding +3), the enchant an item spell succeeds. A result of 1 on the die (d20) always results in failure, regardless of modifications.

The magic-user then casts the required spell(s) upon the item. The first spell must be cast within 24 hours of the completion of enchant an item, or enchant an item fades, although the item can be reenchanted. Any additional spell subsequently cast upon an item bearing an enchant an item spell requires (4 hours) + (4-8 additional hours per spell level) of the magic being cast (where the magic-user can only accomplish work 8 hours / day). Again, during casting, the item must be touched by the magic user, and during rest periods the item must always be within 1’ of his or her person. This procedure holds true for any additional spells placed upon the item, and each successive dweomer must be begun within 24 hours of the last, even if any prior spell failed. While it is possible to tell when the enchant an item spell succeeds, it is not possible to tell if these subsequent spells actually take, and each spell cast requires the same saving throw as the item itself.

No magic placed on the item is permanent without a permanency spell as a finishing touch. When casting the permanency spell on an item, the magic-user need roll 2 or better with d20 to avoid loss of a constitution point. Items with a permanent dweomer (such as weapons, armor, most rings and miscellaneous magic items) require a permanency spell to be made operational. The above-mentioned ring of spell storing could be made without the benefit of a permanency spell, and spells could be stored within, but they could only be called forth once, and then the ring would be useless.

Items that are charged—rods, staves, wands, javelins of lightning, ring of wishes, etc.—can never be made permanent.  The exact spell required to recharge an item will vary. For a wand that can create multiple effects, the spell required for a single charge is typically that which is the highest level spell effect the wand (staff, rod) can produce. *The material components for enchant an item when merely recharging will at a minimum cost the sale value of the item divided by the maximum number of possible charges.

Illusionist

At 11th level an illusionist may create one-shot or charged magic items. The requirements for the Illusionist are generally the same as the magic user, except the illusionist would use major creation instead of enchant an item. During the 16 hours after casting major creation, the illusionist instills the required spells into the item. If their concentration is interrupted even once, the item fades and forever disappears.

Beginning at 14th level an illusionist may attempt permanent items, using a similar process. After major creation has been cast on the item, an alter reality must fix the enchantment permanently in place. Thus, with a great expense in time, money and preparation, major creation, alter reality and true sight spells, and an unflawed gem worth not less than 10,000 gp, an illusionist might be able to create a gem of seeing. For any details in question (e.g., saving throws), what applies to magic-users applies to illusionists as well.

Clerics & Druids

A cleric of at least 11th level (or druids of at least 13th level) can create magic items applicable to their profession. Otherwise, demi-human clerics are sometimes capable of making items with permanent dweomers if they have reached their highest possible level, generally those oriented to the needs and capabilities of the race.

Clerics and druids make items by spending two weeks in retreat, meditating in complete isolation. Thereafter, they must spend a week fasting. Finally, they must pray over and purify the item to become magical for a day (i.e., three weeks and a day).

Of course, the item must be of the finest quality as detailed in enchant an item. Thereafter the cleric or druid must place the item upon their altar and invoke the direct favor of their deity to instill each special power into the item. There is then a 1% per day cumulative chance that the item will be empowered as desired, providing the cleric or druid has been absolutely exemplary in his or her faith and alignment requirements. If the item would not have charges, the item need only be sanctified to the appropriate deity in order to complete its manufacture. Furthermore, if the item would have charges, the cleric or druid must then cast the requisite spell(s) upon it, doing so within 24 hours of its being favored by the deity.

Tolerance Levels for Lack of Food
Combined Strength and Constitution Tolerance Level
15 or less 4 days
16 to 19 5 days
20 to 24 6 days
25 to 30 7 days
31 to 35 8 days
36 or more 10 days

 

If during fasting the character exceeds their tolerance level for lack of food, they must make a successful Strength or Constitution check (whichever is higher) once every 12 hours to remain unaffected by the fasting. Every check after the first has a cumulative +1 modifier. When a character first fails a check, they are weakened, and all subsequent checks have a cumulative +2 modifier. If a character fails a second check, they are distressed. A distressed character continues to incur the penalties for being weakened. If they fail a third check they are incapacitated (and in immediate danger of starving to death). An incapacitated character is incapable of performing any voluntary physical activity, thus ending the creation process.

Research

The process described in the Dragon article “Charging isn’t cheap” suggests that researching an item without a sage cost 2,000 gp per week for a base number of weeks corresponding to the level of magic user required to cast all required spells (e.g., 12th level for the 6th level enchant an item), providing a base chance of success of 10%. Each additional 2,000 gp /week increases that base chance by 10% (to a maximum of 10,000 gp per week and 50% chance of success). After the base period of research is complete, the chance of success is checked each week, calculated as: the base chance, plus 1% per level of the character, plus 1% per intelligence point of the magic user (use wisdom for clerics), minus twice the minimum level required to make the item.

Example: Mae, an 18th-level magic-user, decides to make a staff of the magi. Her intelligence is 18, and she spends 2,000 gp per week. Her chance of success after the initial period is 10% + 18% + 18% – 36% = 10% per week, non-cumulative, for discovering the proper materials and procedures for making the magic item.

The Dragon article also has some useful suggestions for required spell components for some rods, staves, and wands.

*Interpretations

References

TSR 2011, Dungeon Masters Guide [1e], 1979.
TSR 2010, Players Handbook [1e], 1978.
TSR 2020, Wilderness Survival Guide [1e], 1986 (pp. 50-51).
Dragon Magazine, Issue 66, “Sage Advice” October 1982.
Dragon Magazine, Issue 101, “Charging isn’t cheap” September 1985.
Dragon Magazine, Issue 146, “Sage Advice” June 1989.
Dragon Magazine, Issue 147, “Sage Advice” July 1989.

ARRGGHHH I’m Psionic

Last Updated: 231214…250906
psionics@corwyn.net

This article extends my “Oops” series, but psionics are far more of a mess than usual. In the roughly 8 pages discussing psionics between the PHB and DMG , the words that quantify psionics  include: psionic ability, psionic strength total, total psionic ability, psionic ability, total psionic strength, psionic strength, psionic attack strength, psionic defense strength, psionic attack points, and psionic defense points. To exacerbate things, psionics operate by segment, yet AD&D initiative really, well, doesn’t.  Herein lies my attempt to adjust the vocabulary and rules to be understandable but functionally equivalent, filling in the usual gaps. Much like hit points, references to a value or strength are the current value or strength, not the original.

Determining Psionics

Only humans (potentially dwarves, halflings, and rarely elves) can be psionic. Starting characters with an intelligence, wisdom, or charisma of at least 16 roll d100. For each point of intelligence above 16 add 2.5 to the roll, for each point of wisdom above 16 add 1.5 to the roll, and for each point of charisma above 16 add .5 to the roll. Drop any fraction. Any result of 100+ indicates the character has psionic ability.

If so, roll a base d100. Next, determine bonus points: 1 point for each point of intelligence, wisdom and charisma above 12. If 2 of these scores are above 16, the bonus points are doubled. If all 3 scores are above 16, the bonus points are quadrupled. The base (01-100) plus bonus points (4-72), are added together. That number equates to the attack strength, and also the defense strength. Psionic strength always equals (attack strength + defense strength)—a number therefore from 10 to 344.  Psionic strength is used for psionic combat, and in the employment of disciplines.

Should a non-psionic character have their intelligence, wisdom or charisma permanently increase, check again to determine if they have psionic ability. Should intelligence, wisdom or charisma permanently change for a psionic character, adjust the attack and defense strength (and thus psionic strength).  If an ability change leaves the character without at least one necessary 16, they lose their psionic ability (temporarily or permanently, depending). A wish can grant (or remove!) psionics as long as the recipient has a necessary 16 in intelligence, wisdom, or charisma.

Attack Modes

A psionic character can have up to five attack modes. How many are determined by another d100 roll:

01-25 1 attack mode
26-50 2 attack modes
51-75 3 attack modes
76-95 4 attack modes
96-00 5 attack modes

The player then chooses from the five available attack modes:

Attack Mode Attack Strength Cost  per Segment Attack Range4
Short Medium Long
A. Psionic Blast1 20 2″ 4″ 6″
B. Mind Thrust 4 3″ 6″ 9″
C. Ego Whip 7 4″ 8″ 12″
D. Id Insinuation2 10 6″ 12″ 18″
E . Psychic Crush3 14 5″ – –

 1A cone-shaped wave of force 1/2″ diameter at its source and 2″ diameter at its terminus (6″ distance).

2Id Insinuation affects all psionically-aware creatures in a 2″ X 2″ area within the attack range.

3If Psychic Crush is used the attacker may only defend with mode G (Thought Shield), or have no defense at all. Those killed by Psychic Crush lose all psionic abilities if raised or resurrected.

4Expending double or treble the attack strength will double or treble the range of modes B, C, and D.

Defense Modes

A character will also have up to five defense modes. How many are determined by another d100 roll:

01-25 2 defense modes
26-75 3 defense modes
76-90 4 defense modes
91-00 5 defense modes

The player then chooses from the five available defense modes; the first choice must be Mind Blank:

Defense Mode Defense Strength Cost per Segment Area of Effect1
F. Mind Blank 1 Individual only
G. Thought Shield4 2 Individual only
H. Mental Barrier 3 Individual only
I. Intellect Fortress 8 10’r. of individual2
J. Tower of Iron Will 10 3’r. of individual3

1If the defense mode has an area of effect (AoE) beyond the individual, it offers either its defense or the defense used by any individual within its radius, whichever is better.
2Intellect Fortress offers non-psionics in the AoE +2 on saving throws versus Psionic Blast.
3Tower of Iron Will offers non-psionics in the AoE +6 on saving throws versus Psionic Blast.
4If Thought Shield is the only defense mode used in the round, the creature can maintain it while using a discipline, fighting, casting a spell, or being involved in some other activity for the round that does not include any psionic attacks, still at a cost of 2 per segment. Thought Shield is also the only defense that can be used in conjunction with attacking via Psychic Crush.

Psionic Disciplines

A psionic character determines how many disciplines they will have with a d100 roll:

Die Score Number of Minor Disciplines Number of Major Disciplines
01-10 1 0
11-25 2 0
26-40 3 0
41-55 2 1
56-70 3 1
71-80 4 1
81-90 3 2
91-95 5 1
96-100 4 2

After determining the number of disciplines, roll on the Table of Psionic Disciplines (see PHB) for which disciplines are known. If the same discipline is rolled more than once or excluded for the character’s class, re-roll. Select one minor discipline to be begin at first level, with one additional discipline (all minor disciplines first) usable for each 2 additional levels of experience in the character’s class.  The level of mastery is how many character levels the character has had access to the discipline (e.g., a 3rd level character who just gained access to Empathy would use it at 1st level of mastery; at 4th (character) level they would use the discipline at 2nd level of mastery).

The psionic strength cost for disciplines applies to both attack and defense strengths. 1 psionic strength equals 1 attack strength and 1 defense strength.

It is never possible to use two disciplines at the same time, or use an attack mode and a discipline at the same time.

Combined Psionic Operations

Psionic creatures can operate together to increase the range of shared disciplines where range is a factor and otherwise possible. Multiple psionic creatures can link their minds to add a cumulative 50% to the range of a discipline (100% + [n] × 50%, e.g., two individuals have 200% of the range; 3 individuals have 250%, etc.). The base range is always that of the individual in the group with the shortest range.

It is also possible for two or more creatures to increase their psionic strength for psionic combat. Such an operation must be in “series”, with the creatures adding 20% of their current psionic strength (half attack strength, half defense strength, all fractions rounded up) to the next individual in the series. Example: Creature A has a psionic strength of 100, so 20 psionic strength (10 attack strength, 10 defense strength) are transferred to creature B to bring its total from 120 to 140, and B then transfers 28 psionic strength (again, 20%) to creature C whose psionic strength is 130 but is now 158s, and then C transfers 158 × .20, or 32 psionic strength to final creature D. All series begin from the creature with the lowest psionic strength. The final creature in the series attacks and defends for all in the series. Only the final creature in the series can psionically attack or be attacked. All psionic strength used first comes from the transferred psionic strength. All creatures in the series will be affected by all psionic attacks affecting the final creature.

The series is maintained even for distracted creatures; they are unable to attack or defend (psionically or otherwise) until the series is dissolved by the lead creature in the series. Dissolving the series also removes the transferred psionic strength. The death or distraction of a creature earlier in the series will not disrupt the series.

Recovery

Psionic strength can be restored by refraining from psionic activity. Disciplines which do not require continuing strength point outlay can be in operation during recovery periods. No psionic strength can be recovered in less than one-hour increments.   The rate of restoration depends upon the activity level:

Physical Activity1, 2 Psionic Strength Recovered (half attack, half defense)
hard exertion none
walking and like activity 3 psionic strength  / hour
sitting and talking or reading 6 psionic strength / hour
resting and meditating 12 psionic strength / hour
sleeping 12 psionic strength / hour

1The least favorable activity is considered for each hour of time spent in restoration of psionic strength.
2Psionic strength can be recovered on the Astral plane at the rate of 6 psionic strength / hour when moving by mental effort, and 12 psionic strength/hour when “floating” and not thinking of moving.

Psionic Combat

Psionic combat is a declared action for a round, but starting on the first segment of the round regardless of initiative (potentially superseding the declared action of others now abruptly psionic combatants). Psionic combat can occur during Surprise if the initiator’s party is unsurprised. In that case, psionic combat will occur on each segment of surprise—both sides interact psionically as normal (both attack and defense) for each segment of Surprise.

Each psionic attack or defense will cost attack or defense strength (respectively), depending on the selected attack mode, defense mode, and resulting outcome. Creatures using a defense mode can take another action (using an attack mode, discipline, OR a segment of movement). Creatures using an attack mode cannot engage in any other activity but using a defense mode. If a creature is distracted by physical attack or spell damage or effect (such as charm, hold, etc.) it cannot make further psionic attacks or take other actions that round (but could resume the next round), although a distracted creature can still utilize defense modes.

There is one exception—Thought Shield. A psionic combatant who selects Thought Shield in the first segment of psionic combat can maintain this defense mode (spending defense strength each segment) while pursuing another non-psionic action for the round (or during surprise). However, taking a non-psionic action precludes making any psionic attacks for the entirety of the round.

Psionic vs. Psionic

All psionic attacks and defenses are simultaneous. Psionic combat (presuming Creatures A & B) takes place by segment, starting on the first segment of the round:

  1. Determine A & B’s current psionic strength (attack strength + defense strength).
  2. A & B announce their own attack mode (from those they have available).
    1. If all attack strength is expended, or not enough attack strength remains to use any attack mode available, the creature may defend only.
  3. A & B only then choose their own defense mode (using the most applicable from those available).
  4. Compare each creature’s attack mode and psionic strength to their opponent’s chosen defense on the appropriate Psionic vs. Psionic table, Appendix A(Short Range), or Appendix B (Medium/Long Range).
    1. Long range attacks reduce the attacker’s effective psionic strength by 25 for purposes of the table
  5. Psionic attacks at short range reduce each creature’s defense strength by the defense cost (see Appendix A). Psionic attacks at medium and long range reduce that damage by 20% (see Appendix B). If the attack was long range, and originally in the 1-25 point range for psionic strength, damage is reduced by 50% instead of 20%. Any results beyond that required to bring the defense strength to 0 is applied to hit points.
  6. Reduce each creature’s attack strength by the cost of their attack, taking into account any increased cost for increasing the range.
  7. Repeat this sequence each segment for 10 segments, or until neither side makes a psionic attack during a segment.

Defenseless Psionics

Once a psionic creature’s defense strength reaches 0 (or has no available defense mode), later psionic attacks are determined on the Psionic Vs. Defenseless Psionic table (see Appendix C):

  • Determine the attacker’s attack strength and attack mode.
  • Determine the defender’s psionic strength (typically equal to their attack strength, as defense strength likely equals 0).
  • Compare the attacker’s attack strength and attack mode to the defender’s psionic strength (e.g., their attack strength) on the Psionic Vs. Defenseless Psionic table (see Appendix C).
    • A number result on the table reduces the defender’s psionic strength, defense strength first. If the attack strength reaches 0, reduce the defender’s hit points by the remainder of the number.
    • If the result is a letter, apply that result to the defender.
      For a defender with mind bar, letter results only apply when the psionic strength is 0 at the beginning of the segment, otherwise they lose 40 psionic strength (half attack strength, half defense strength first, and then any remaining psionic strength), applying any leftover results to hit points.

Psionic Blast on non-Psionics

Only psionic blast can affect non-psionic creatures, and only if the psionically-attacking creature has an attack strength of 100+.   Each non-psionic potentially affected by psionic blast rolls a “saving throw” (See Appendix D) based on their total intelligence and wisdom to avoid the effect, adjusted by various factors:

 

Attacked Creature’s
Int + Wisdom
Saving Throw
0-5 20
6-9 18
10-13 16
14-17 14
18-21 12
22-25 10
26-29 8
30-33 6
34-35 4
36-37 2
38 & up 0

 

Saving Throw Adjustments
Bonuses   Penalties
medium range +1   panicked -1
long range +2   enraged -1
magic-user +1   confused -2
cleric +2   hopeless -3
elf +2   stunned -3
Intellect Fortress within 10′ +2   using psionic-related power2 -4
mink blank spell +2   using ESP -5
dwarf +4   feebleminded3 –
halfling +4   insane4 –
helm of telepathy1 +4      
Tower of Iron Will within 3′ +6      
mind bar +6      
protection items valid against “all forms of attack”5 +x      

1The helm of telepathy will cause the attacker to be stunned for 1-4 rounds if the defender’s saving throw is successful.

2These powers or spells are: astral protection/spell, augury, charm monster, charm person, clairaudience, clairvoyance, confusion, detect evil/good, detect magic, dimension door, divination, empathy, enlarge, ESP, etherealness, feeblemind, feign death, geas, invisibility (any sort), know alignment, levitation, locate object, magic jar, plane shift, polymorph self, quest, shape change, suggestion, symbol, telekinesis, telepathy, teleportation, true seeing

3A feebleminded person has a combined intelligence and wisdom score of 0-5.

4Insane creatures cannot be psionically attacked.

5rings and cloaks of protection

In the Psionic Blast on Non-Psionics table (Appendix D), the attacked creature’s total intelligence and wisdom is used to figure saving throws. However, wisdom is not a standard given attribute of monsters. To compute the wisdom of non-psionic monsters, use the following table:

Intelligence of Creature Wisdom Range
Below Low 0
Low 2d4
Average 3d4
Very/Highly 4d4
Exceptional/Genius 2d6+6
Supra-Genius 4d4+4
Godlike 3d6+6

Random Encounters

If a random encounter occurs when the party has used psionic powers during the last turn (or spells resembling disciplines during the last round), there is a 1 in 4 chance the encounter is psionic. If so, use the Psionic Encounter Table instead. The psionic encounter otherwise occurs as normal, although certain psionic creatures will not be detected by the party.

Modifying Psionics

A wish can create the potential to be psionic (assuming the necessary ability score of 16). A wish can also bestow immunity to one particular attack mode; immunity to all attack modes precludes using any disciplines.

As a character ages, their intelligence and wisdom also change.  Adjust the psionic strength.

The following mechanisms increase a character’s psionic strength (half to attack strength, half to defense strength). This strength will be spent before the innate strength, and recover at the same time as the psionic strength at the same rate:

  • The helm of telepathy increases psionic strength by 40 (in additional to providing a +4 to saving throws vs. Psionic Blast).
  • A dull gray ioun stone increases psionic strength by 10, to a maximum of 50 (e.g. 5 ioun stones)
  • Ioun stones which merely increase intelligence, wisdom, or charisma will not increase the creature’s psionic abilities, as psionic strength is determined by unmodified ability scores.

References

TSR 2010, Players Handbook [1e], 1978.
TSR 2011, Dungeon Masters Guide [1e], 1979.
TSR 2013, Deities & Demigods, 1980.
Dragon Magazine Issue 35, The official errata: Scads of additions & Revisions for AD&D. [Errata removes psionic elves]
Dragon Magazine Issue 39, Sage Advice. [Only humans, possibly dwarves and halflings]
Dragon Magazine Issue 42, Sage Advice. [Limit psionic elves to NPCs, MM]
Dragon Magazine Issue 58, Sage Advice. [Dwarves and psionics]
Dragon Magazine Issue 60, The Elven Point of View.  [Elves not psionic]
Dragon Magazine Issue 67, The Astral Plane, 1982. [EGG added elves psionic]
Dragon Magazine Issue 67, Featured Creatures, 1982. [potential for psionic valley elves]
Dragon Magazine Issue 71, Solid answers to astral questions. [Psionics and Astral]
Dragon Magazine Issue 78, Psionics is different.  [All PCs can be psionic, ability score changes]
Dragon Magazine Issue 78, Sage Advice.  [All PCs psionic, ability score changes]

 

Appendix A: Psionic vs. Psionic in Mental Combat (Short Range)

 

Attacker Psionic Strength Attack Mode Attack Cost Defense Cost (ordered by “best”)1,2
01-25 Psionic Blast 20 Mind Blank(4), MR(7),IF/TS(9)
01-25 Mind Thrust 4 Mental Barrier(3), TS(6), IF(8), TW(11)
01-25 Ego Whip 7 Mental Barrier(3), TS(5), IF(8), MB(9)
01-25 Id Insinuation 10 Mind Blank(2), TS(8), IF(9), MR/TW(11)
01-25 Psychic Crush 14 Though Shield(2), MR(3), IF(8)3
26-50 Psionic Blast 20 Mind Blank(7), MR(9),IF/TW(10)
26-50 Mind Thrust 4 Mental Barrier(4), TS/IF(8), MR(3)
26-50 Ego Whip 7 Mental Barrier, TS(6), IF(8), TW(10)
26-50 Id Insinuation 10 Mind Blank(3), TS(10), IF(11), MR/TW(13)
26-50 Psychic Crush 14 Intellect Fortress(8), TW(10), MR(3), TS(2)3
51-75 Psionic Blast 20 Mind Blank/Tower(11), MR/IF(12)
51-75 Mind Thrust 4 Mental Barrier(5), IF(10), TS(11),TW(13)
51-75 Ego Whip 7 Mental Barrier(4), TS(8), IF(9), TW(11)
51-75 Id Insinuation 10 Mind Blank(5), TS(13), IF(15), MR/TW(16)
51-75 Psychic Crush 14 Tower of Iron Will(10), IF(8), MR(3), TW(2)3
76-100 Psionic Blast 20 Tower of Iron Will(12), IF(15),MB/MR(16)
76-100 Mind Thrust 4 Mental Barrier(8), IF(12), TS/TW(15)
76-100 Ego Whip 7 Mental Barrier(6), IF(10), TS(11), TW(15)
76-100 Id Insinuation 10 Mind Blank(8), TS(17), Other(20)
76-100 Psychic Crush 14 Tower of Iron Will(10), IF(8), MR(3), TS(2)3
101-125 Psionic Blast 20 Tower of Iron Will(14), IF(19), MR(21), MB(22)
101-125 Mind Thrust 4 Mental Barrier(12), IF(15), TW(18), TS(20)
101-125 Ego Whip 7 Mental Barrier(9), IF(12), TS(15), TW(16)
101-125 Id Insinuation 10 Mind Blank(12), TS(22), MR/TW(25)
101-125 Psychic Crush 14 Tower of Iron Will(10), IF(8), MR(3), TS(2)3
126+ Psionic Blast 20 Tower of Iron Will (17), IF(24), MR(27), MB/TS(29)
126+ Mind Thrust 4 Intellect Fortress/MR(19), TW(22), TS(26)
126+ Ego Whip 7 Mental Barrier(12), IF(15),TS/TW(20)
126+ Id Insinuation 10 Mind Blank(17), TS(28), IF/TW(31)
126+ Psychic Crush 14 Tower of Iron Will(10), IF(8), MB(3), TS(2)3

 

1MB – Mind Blank, MR – Mental Barrier

2This table takes into account the sum of the defense mode cost and the damage cost.

3Calculations for Psychic Crush select the most efficient defense least likely to cause instant death.

 

Appendix B: Psionic vs. Psionic in Mental Combat (Medium/Long Range)

        Defense Cost1
Attacker Psionic Strength Attack Mode Cost Mind Blank Thought Shield Mental Barrier Intellect Fortress Tower of Iron Will
01-25 Psionic Blast 20   3 8 6 9 10
01-25 Mind Thrust 4 11 5 3 8 11
01-25 Ego Whip 7   7 4 3 8 10
01-25 Id Insinuation 10 2 7 9 9 11
01-25 Psychic Crush 14   1 2 3 8 10
26-50 Psionic Blast 20 6 9 8 10 10
26-50 Mind Thrust 4   13 7 4 8 12
26-50 Ego Whip 7 11 5 3 8 10
26-50 Id Insinuation 10   3 8 11 10 12
26-50 Psychic Crush 14 1 2 3 8 10
51-75 Psionic Blast 20   9 12 10 11 11
51-75 Mind Thrust 4 15 9 5 10 12
51-75 Ego Whip 7   15 7 4 9 11
51-75 Id Insinuation 10 4 11 13 14 15
51-75 Psychic Crush 14   1 2 3 8 10
76-100 Psionic Blast 20 13 15 13 14 12
76-100 Mind Thrust 4   19 12 7 11 14
76-100 Ego Whip 7 19 9 5 10 12
76-100 Id Insinuation 10   7 14 17 18 18
76-100 Psychic Crush 14 1 2 3 8 10
101-125 Psionic Blast 20   18 19 17 17 13
101-125 Mind Thrust 4 22 16 10 14 16
101-125 Ego Whip 7   25 12 8 11 15
101-125 Id Insinuation 10 10 18 21 22 22
101-125 Psychic Crush 14   1 2 3 8 10
126+ Psionic Blast 20 23 24 22 21 16
126+ Mind Thrust 4   25 21 16 17 20
126+ Ego Whip 7 31 16 11 14 18
126+ Id Insinuation 10   14 23 25 28 27
126+ Psychic Crush 14 1 2 3 8 10

1This table takes into account the sum of the defense mode cost and the damage cost.

Appendix C: Psionic vs. Defenseless Psionic

Defender’s Psionic Strength (Attack Strength + Defense Strength)
Attack Strength Attack Mode 10-59 60-109 110-159 160-209 210-259 260-309 310+
01-25 Psionic Blast D C C 15 10 5 5
01-25 Mind Thrust W W 40 35 30 25 20
01-25 Ego Whip 30 25 20 15 10 5 5
01-25 Id Insinuation 40 35 30 25 20 15 10
01-25 Psychic Crush 72% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10%
26-50 Psionic Blast S D C C 15 10 5
26-50 Mind Thrust W W W 40 35 30 25
26-50 Ego Whip 35 30 25 20 15 10 5
26-50 Id Insinuation R 40 35 30 25 20 15
26-50 Psychic Crush 75% 62% 52% 42% 32% 22% 12%
51-75 Psionic Blast W S D C C 15 10
51-75 Mind Thrust P W W W 40 35 30
51-75 Ego Whip 40 35 30 25 20 15 10
51-75 Id Insinuation R R 40 35 30 25 20
51-75 Psychic Crush 79% 65% 55% 45% 35% 25% 15%
76-100 Psionic Blast P W S D C C 15
76-100 Mind Thrust P P W W W 40 35
76-100 Ego Whip P 40 35 30 25 20 15
76-100 Id Insinuation R R R 40 35 30 25
76-100 Psychic Crush 84% 69% 59% 49% 39% 29% 19%
100-125 Psionic Blast K P W S D C C
100-125 Mind Thrust P P P W W W 40
100-125 Ego Whip I P 40 35 30 25 20
100-125 Id Insinuation R R R R 40 35 30
100-125 Psychic Crush 90% 74% 64% 54% 44% 34% 24%
126 & up Psionic Blast K K P W S D C
126 & up Mind Thrust P P P P W W W
126 & up Ego Whip I I P 40 35 30 25
126 & up Id Insinuation R R R R R 40 35
126 & up Psychic Crush 97% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30%

 

C             Confused for 2-8 rounds, Only non-psionic activity possible

D             Dazed for 1-4 turns, no psionic or other activity

I               Idiocy, psionic ability lost forever, idiocy only curable by a heal spell

K             Killed, raising/resurrection is possible, but psionic ability is lost

P             Permanent loss of random attack/defense/ discipline, and dazed as above

S              Sleeping in a coma for 1-4 weeks (catatonic state 99% likely to be mistaken for death)

R             Robot, mind is controlled by victor until released or after 2-8 weeks a saving throw versus magic

W            Wounded psionically. Randomly determine an attack/ defense/ discipline unusable for 2-8 weeks

 

A number result reduces the defender’s psionic strength, defense strength first. If the attack strength reaches 0, reduce the defender’s hit points by the remainder of the number.  Psionic creatures with mind bar discipline will take damage only on a segment after all psionic strength is lost, so treat letter results as a 40 until 0 is reached. If psionic strength is reduced beyond 0, treat it as hit point damage on a point-for-point basis.

 

 

Appendix D: Psionic Blast on Non-Psionics

Attacked Creature’s Total Intelligence and Wisdom Saving Throw Death Coma Sleep Stun Confuse Enrage Panic Feebleminded Permanent Insanity Temporary Insanity Mild Insanity
0-5 20 01-85 86-99 00 – – – – – – – –
6-9 18 01-10 11-90 91-99 00 – – – – – – –
10-13 16 01 02-15 16-90 91-99 00 – – – – – –
14-17 14 – 01 02-10 11-90 91-99 00 – – – – –
18-21 20 – – 01 02-15 16-90 91-99 00 – – – –
22-25 10 – – – 01 02-15 16-90 91-99 00 – – –
26-29 8 – – – – 01 02-15 16-90 91-99 00 – –
30-33 6 – – – – – 01 02-15 16-90 91-99 00 –
34-35 4 – – – – – – 01 02-20 21-85 86-99 00
36-37 2 – – – – – – – 01 02-15 16-90 91-00
38 & up 0 – – – – – – – – 01 02-15 16-00

 

DEATH:                                 Creature can be brought back to life as is usual.

COMA:                                2-12 days where creature cannot be awakened.

SLEEP:                                   5-20 turns where creature cannot be awakened.

STUN:                                   2-8 turns where character is at usual stunned condition (-3 on saves vs. psionic blast, +4 to hit).

CONFUSE:                           1-4 turns as per the spell of the same name.

ENRAGE:                             2-8 rounds and creature affected must immediately launch a spell or physical attack upon any opponent or other creature. During enraged period, creature will not think of defense or any action save attacking.

PANIC:                                  2-8 rounds with reaction as a fear spell from a 4th level magic user.

FEEBLEMIND:                     This lasts until a heal, restoration, or wish is used. The creature’s combined intelligence & wisdom is in the 0-5 range when so affected. All memory of spells is gone, and the affected creature cannot attack or defend.

1PERMANENT INSANITY: This lasts until a heal, restoration, or wish is used. Select two forms of insanity from the table therein, and have affected creature behave accordingly as long as the condition lasts.

1TEMPORARY INSANITY:               2-1 2 weeks duration, otherwise as above.

1MILD INSANITY:              1-4 weeks duration, one form of insanity only, otherwise as above.

1In most cases the fact that the creature has been inflicted with insanity will NOT be immediately evident to associates. Behavior will make the condition suspect as appropriate to the form of affliction.

What Do You Know?

Last updated: 210920…230313

The Player’s Handbook includes the Intelligence “Chance to Know” for Magic User and Illusionist spells. In short, Mages can’t learn some spells, determined based on their intelligence. Which doesn’t quite integrate with the DMG, UA or OA. Of course.

 

“Each and every magic-user character must employ the Table [for minimum and maximum number of spells /level] in order to determine which and how many of each group of spells (by level) he or she can learn.”, PHB, p. 10.

A “level group” includes all of the spells of a particular level. During character creation, the mage rolls the Chance to Know for the Level 1 level group. When the mage can cast Level 2 spells (i.e., a Level 3 mage), the mage rolls for the Level 2 level group, etc. The mage makes “a complete check of each spell in the level group” for Chance to Know, in the order of their choosing (see Maximum Number below however). Any spell that passes the Chance to Know roll will be able to be comprehended, learned, and memorized once acquired. Any spell that fails the Chance to Know roll likely cannot ever be understood by the mage (see Write and Change of Intelligence however).

The Minimum Number is a safety net for the rare case where too few spells could be understood. After all, what’s the fun of playing a mage who can only understand a single spell! If the minimum number isn’t reached after rolling Chance to Know for the entire level group, the player works through the list of spells that failed on the first pass (again, in any order they wish), checking one spell at a time until they reach the Minimum Number.

Some groups delay rolling Chance to Know until each individual spell discovery, but that’s flawed. The Minimum is the reason “one complete check” (PHB, p. 10) of a new level group is done, since if the minimum is not reached  any mage rolling below the minimum wouldn’t be able to recheck the level group until encountering all of the spells of the level group—an unlikely event!

 

The Maximum Number defines the spells that could be learned. As written, while rolling Chance to Know for a level group, If the maximum is reached, the character may not ever check any further in the level group (see Change of Intelligence). However, applying the Maximum to the Chance to Know roll for the level group creates significant issues, given that for the low-level spells the mage will mathematically almost certainly reach their maximum (even if you don’t roll for the UA spells) long before reaching the end of the spell group:

  • The mage won’t be able to create new spells (as they will have already reached their maximum on the initial Chance to Know roll).
  • If the mage discovers a “heretofore unknown” spell , they will already have reached their maximum, so be unable to even roll Chance to Know.
  • For a mage with a low intelligence, they will start with only 2-3 additional 1st level spells they can cast, and they have to find those specific spells. Even a mage with an 18 Intelligence will only have 14 Level 1 spells they can cast, so never even roll Chance to Know for the majority of spells they find.

The text itself is contradictory, as Maximum is also defined as the maximum a mage can have in their spell books. For me, I apply the Maximum only to those spells that have actually been learned (in their spell book, memorizable and castable). Check the entire level group; the mage can choose to learn on discovery what spells to learn, up to the maximum.

That also means that for all practical purposes, if the Minimum Number of Spells/Level is reached, the mage can stop checking, and check any remaining spells at time of discovery. It also prevents consigning mages with a lower Intelligence to a fate of seeking those missing spells—they can just decide, with each spell the find, whether to add it to their list of learned spells (after checking Chance to Know).

The 1st Level Mage

The intelligence of the mage dictates which spells can be known (DMG, p. 39). The 1st Level mage first rolls Chance to Know for the entire level group of 1st level spells. They then add to their spell book Read Magic and three additional spells randomly selected by the DM (although on a roll of “0” the player may choose). Obviously, an apprentice must know Read Magic to be of use to his master—they cannot fail this roll. At the same time, Read Magic is one of the minimum number of spells that can be comprehended, as well as counting towards one of the maximum number of spells learned.

The three additional spells is defined with flexibility, as:

“If your campaign is particularly difficult, you may wish to allow choice automatically. You can furthermore allow an extra defensive or miscellaneous spell, so that the character begins with 5 spells.” DMG, p. 39.

As the mage defaults to four spells to seek their fortune, if a roll to determine those three additional spells specifies a spell that can’t be comprehended (due to a failed Chance to Know roll), the spell category (offense, defense, misc.) should be rolled again. That aligns with “While the intelligence of the player character will dictate how many and which spells can be and are known, this knowledge is not automatic” (DMG, p. 39) and incorporates the illusionist “ignoring any rolls that result in duplication”; rolling again is the simplest solution. Certainly the intent is not to have a mage without usable spells in their starting spell book!

The illusionist originally followed a different process than the magic-user for starting spells, rolling d12 against the entire 1st level illusionist level group (rerolling duplicates), with the DM allowing an additional one to two spells for a difficult campaign (DMG, p. 39). UA aligned that process to the magic user, rolling on a table of offensive, defensive, and misc. spells, expanded to include UA spells (UA, p. 80).

Acquiring New Spells

Mages acquire new spells from three sources: one spell upon gaining a level, discovery of scrolls and spell books, and spell creation. The Maximum Number of Spells/Level comes into play whenever acquiring new spells.

“…it is possible to acquire knowledge of additional spells previously unknown as long as this does not violate the maximum number of spells which can be known.” (PHB, p. 10).

Any future spells discovered that have not yet had Chance to Know determined are considered unknown (see Spell Discovery), and are checked at time of discovery if the mage has not reached their Maximum Number of Spells / Level.

 

There’s no exception defined for a mage that has reached their Maximum: “As soon as this maximum is reached, the character may not check any further in the level group” (PHB, p. 10). That said, it’s easy enough to house rule the mage can drop a spell. We play that to learn a spell —in the rare case that Maximum Knowable has been reached—the mage loses one spell at random. A more lenient style would permit the player to choose the spell to be lost.

Gaining a Level

When a mage gains a new level beyond the first, two things happen. If they’ve gained access to a new level group, they check Chance to Know for all of the spells of that level group to confirm minimum (and likely maximum) spells. They also gain a new spell (DMG, p. 39).

Polyhedron #30 (JUL 1986) article DISPEL CONFUSION wrote:

“It is up to the individual DM to determine whether new spells are assigned or given by choice in a particular campaign. In either case, the “chance to know” roll still applies, and the character may or may not be given a chance to choose another spell if the first offering call not be learned. Also, the DM may choose to make only certain spells available through the training process, so the choice may be limited.”

Where does that spell come from when they gain a level? The DM can certainly allow a player to select any spell upon leveling (effectively, creating it). However, the rules for spell creation, which involve money, time, a library, and a chance of failure don’t align with the timeframe and costs for training. Gygax (Dragon, January, 1980) also states:
“even if a spell-caster is capable of knowing/memorizing many and high-level spells, he or she must find them (in the case of Magic-Users and Illusionists) or have the aid of deities or minions thereof (in the situation faced by Clerics and Druids)” and “The ramifications of spell scarcity are bound to aid your campaign.” Spells should be hard to acquire, and don’t just appear ready-to-use.

The trainer providing a scroll, or a spell from their own spell book, is more consistent with those philosophies than the player just choosing what they want. The trainer could, of course, offer his student a choice of the spells within his spell book. Or not. That leaves open where the mage acquires the spell when leveling without a trainer/tutor—a scroll acquired as part of the increased training cost is one explanation.

Spell Discovery

As long as the mage hasn’t learned their Maximum Knowable spells for the spell group, they can learn additional spells.

When a mage discovers a spell they can comprehend (determined by the earlier Chance to Know) in a spell book or scroll, they can add it to their spell book (after casting Read Magic to know that they know it!). Transcribing a scroll into a spell book requires one day for each spell level (e.g., a 3rd level spell takes three days) before the spell can be memorized.

When the mage discovers a heretofore unknown spell that has never had the Chance to Know rolled, and has not reached their Maximum, they roll the Chance to Know. Success means they can comprehend and learn the spell. How could they encounter a spell without a previous Chance to Know roll? That spell could be a unique spell created by a module or campaign, or was otherwise previously unavailable. As an example, my campaigns don’t check the UA spells at character creation; when a UA spell is discovered, the mage determines Chance to Know.

Creating New Spells

The mage can also research new spells by creating them (DMG, p. 115). Whether the spell is new, or a listed spell the character has been unable to locate during the course of adventuring, the mage can attempt to create the spell as long as they have not reached the Maximum for that spell group.

The player presents to the GM the specifics of the desired spell, after which the GM determines the spell level (DMG, p. 115). If the GM determines the spell level is above the level the mage can cast, research is possible, but useless. If the spell caster doesn’t spend enough money on research, there will never be success. In either case, there will be no indication that their attempt is fruitless. The DMG instructs that the player will be unaware of the specifics of the calculation. Even if the spell creation is impossible, the DM should still permit them to keep throwing their gold away week after week until they give up. For a game 40+ years old, that’s unlikely and impractical—the GM and player should be in accord for the spell level. At the very least the GM should permit the mage to consult a sage to determine spell level.

With access to a library within one day’s travels (or a shrine, in the case of a cleric), researching a new spell requires a minimum number of weeks equal to the determined spell level. Any day of interruption will set progress back one week. The research cost for each week will be:  a base cost of 200 gp / spell level per week + a variable 100-400 gp / spell level each week for materials. If no library is at hand, the base cost increases by a factor of 10 (from 200 gp to 2000 gp)!  After the minimum research period, the base chance of creating the spell that week (and each week thereafter) is 10%, modified by intelligence, mage level, and spell level:  ((10 + Intelligence + mage level) – (2 × spell level)))%.

For each additional 2,000 gp spent per spell level, the base chance can be further increased by 10%, (i.e., for a first level spell an additional 2,000 gp/spell level for a 20% base, and additional 4,000 gp for a 30% base, an additional 6,000 gp for a 40% base, and an additional 8,000 gp for a 50% base (the maximum)).

Unearthed Arcana

Unearthed Arcana defines a heretofore undefined capacity for spell books. A standard spell book, with an encumbrance of 450 gp) is composed of 72 pages of thick vellum, and can contain only a limited number of spells—spells of levels 1-3 use three pages each, spells of levels 4-6 use six pages each, and spells of the levels 7-9 require nine full pages each.

UA also adds the spell and requirement of the 1st level Read Magic to the Illusionist, and a table for the initial illusionist spells, making the illusionist spell process virtually identical to the magic user.

Write

The Write spell will: “inscribe a spell he or she cannot understand at the time (due to level or lack of sufficient intelligence) into the tome or other compilation he or she employs to maintain a library of spells.”

Write conveys no additional abilities. Mages can’t automatically comprehend spells inscribed in a spell book; that’s superseded by the Chance to Know roll.

Combining Write with UA, Write could inscribe a spell into a spell book, to later be cast, in extremis, just as if the spell book were a scroll. But that still doesn’t negate the Chance to Know—UA requires the spell to be knowable in such a circumstance (differing from casting an unknowable spell from scroll, which is permitted (DMG, p. 128)).

Change in Intelligence

“If intelligence goes down or up for any reason, and such change is relatively permanent, the magic-user must check again as explained above for known spells by level group.”

On first glance, a change in mage intelligence completely randomizes their spell selection. However, a closer read shows “for known spells”. If the Intelligence decreases, OA states that Chance to Know is checked for known spells until enough spells are forgotten to comply with a new Maximum. The wise mage will first check those spells that passed Chance to Know buy have yet to be discovered!

On increase, the mage begins their check anew, re-checking each level group in the order of their choosing for additional spells until they have reached their new Maximum.

Oriental Adventures

OA includes a number of statements in the context of the wu jen, all more definitively stated than the original text in the PHB:

  • Chance to Know is checked for every spell at the time the mage gains access to a new spell group.
    • If the Minimum is not reached, start checking again, one spell at a time, until the Minimum is reached.
    • If the Maximum is reached while checking Chance to Know, stop.
  • If a spell that has not failed Chance to Know is encountered “in the field”, the mage can check Chance to Know if not at Maximum.

References

 

TSR 2010, Players Handbook [1e], 1978.
TSR 2011, Dungeon Masters Guide [1e], 1979.
Dragon Magazine, Issue 33, “Sorceror’s Scroll: AD&D’s Magic System: How and Why it Works,” January, 1980.
TSR 2017, Unearthed Arcana [1e], 1985.
TSR 2018, Oriental Adventures [1e], 1985. p. 25. [Not quite identical to PHB]
Dragon Magazine, Issue 139, “Sage Advice,” November 1988.
Dragon Magazine, Issue 147, “Spelling it Out,” July, 1989. [Not consistent with RAW]

A Skilled Conversion of Proficiencies

Last Updated: 210914..230107

I have a love/hate relationship with Proficiencies. Proficiencies can be a great way to add flavor to a PC. Yet when comparing proficiencies to Class abilities, proficiencies are disproportionately effective (initial thief functions are only 25%). The very word—”proficient”—implies a high level of success.

The proficiency system in 1e biases heavily towards high stats. 1e uses a class-based system, but should all classes be equal for the same proficiencies? There’s no explicit adjustment for tasks of varying difficulty. Proficiencies don’t advance with experience. To exemplify the issue that proficiencies aren’t quite right, each edition uses a different system. Even 1e uses more than one system (Oriental Adventures *cough*).

Here’s an alternate skill system derived primarily on the Dragon Magazine #225 system, and vaguely similar to OA with different checks. Skills are weaker to start, but improve as a PC levels.

A character starts with a certain number of skills, which can be improved or expanded upon as the character levels. When performing a skill check, the player rolls a d20, and is successful if they roll equal to or less than the target number. Skill checks are modified for the difficulty of the task, but difficulty of the task is determined based on the PC’s skill level.

  • Standard proficiency slots per class + Intelligence bonus determine Skill Slots available to acquire or improve new skills.
  • A specific skill provides a base 10 target number +/- a skill modifier, representing the intrinsic difficulty or simplicity of that particular skill (e.g., Alchemy, based on Intelligence, has a -3 target number penalty, i.e., a base target number of 7).
  • The ability score associated with the particular skill modifies the target number:
Ability score modifier
12 +1
13 +1
14 +1
15 +2
16 +2
17 +3
18 +3
  • Non-Fighters have a -1 penalty on STRENGTH proficiencies, and a +2 max bonus on CONSTITUTION skills (aligning Strength checks more closely to the ability tables).
  • Learning a skill that mimics a class skill from another class incurs an additional -6 target number penalty.
  • Multi-class characters start with a number of skills equal to the total proficiency slots from both classes, and earn new skill slots at the proficiency rate of the fastest class.
    • Specializing in a skill (using an additional slot) improves the base target number by 3 (journeyman).
    • Double specializing (spending two additional slots) will improve the skill target number by an additional 2 (master). Further specialization will improve the skill target by 1 for each additional point spent.
  • Each level the PC gains 1 additional point to improve/increase one previously-selected skill’s target number of their choice by 1 point (multi-class characters get 1 each time they reach a new highest level).
    • The player must choose which skill will be modified upon gaining the new level.
    • Unlike gaining new slots, the experience modifier may not be saved from level to level. If they are not assigned, they are lost.
    • The player may select any of the character’s previously-selected skills to improve. The only restriction on this choice is that a newly-acquired skill cannot be chosen.
    • The skill target number is then modified further by the associated ability score.
  • Attempts can be made against an unlearned skill, with base target number of 0.
  • When two characters with the same skill work together on the same task, use the score of the player with the best skill (the one with the greatest chance of success). Furthermore, a minimum of +1 bonus is added for the other character’s assistance (+1 for each additional point they have added to the skill). The bonus can never be from more than 1 PC; too many assistants are sometimes worse than having none.
  • To determine success, Roll d20 <= the modified target number based on the difficulty of the particular task for someone who knows the skill:
Modifier to Target number
Easy +5
Average 0
Hard -5
Very hard -10
Nearly impossible -15
  • Always fail on a 20. Success on a 1 is not guaranteed.
  • When there are opposed skill checks, use the delta of success to determine success.
  • Where applicable, acquiring a skill conveys the initial expectation of apprentice-level ability, not mastery. In other words, determine the difficulty as if the PC was an apprentice, not a master. If the PC has spent 2 proficiency slots, then determine difficulty as if the PC were a journeyman, and 3 (or more) slots as if they were a master.

Optional*

Buying a non-class skill costs 1 more slot. Class skills are a combination of DRMG 225 and 2e, leaning towards permissive.

F Fighter Paladins are also Clerics, Rangers are also Magic Users, Barbarians are also Thieves
M Magic User  
C Cleric Druids are also Fighters
T Thief  
B Bard  
K Monk Monks are also Thieves

*I apply this only to skills that replicate class-like abilities.

Bibliography

TSR 2018, Oriental Adventures [1e], 1985.
TSR 2019, Dungeoneer’s Survival Guide [1e], 1986.
TSR 2020, Wilderness Survival Guide [1e], 1986.
Dragon Magazine, Issue 224, “Back in the Saddle (Again) January 1996.

Potion Creation

Last Updated: 221011…240621

(This article has been supplanted by The Alchemy of Potions)

How do PCs create potions? For years I’ve assumed there’s two stages: a) the mage researches the formula, b) the mage creates the potion. But is that really how it works?

In addition to the Alchemist expert hireling in the DMG, Dragon magazine includes not one but four different variations of the alchemist (#002, #046, #049, #130). The alchemist is also discussed in the 2e Player’s Options (Skills & Powers, Spells & Magic). Several include the research component:

  • Dragon #002: “Research costs are the same as MUs for Spells”
  • Dragon #130: “The DM adjudicates the alchemist’s success in research. The costs for research is at least 50-300 GP per level of the potion desired.”
  • Skills & Powers: “The alchemist must first research the potion’s formula, as if conducting normal spell research.”

Yet per the DMG: “In order to find out [how to fabricate magic items], they must consult with a sage (q.v.) or a high level character of the proper profession, the latter being detailed a bit hereafter.” where the only item that requires consulting with someone “of the proper profession” is potion creation and the alchemist. The only requirement for a 7th level magic-user (or presumably 7th level cleric in the case of healing potions) to concoct a potion is hiring an alchemist (and even that requirement is removed when the magic-user reaches 12th level).

So, the magic-user needs:

  1. an alchemist
  2. a lab/workshop
  3. the appropriate special ingredient
  4. manufacturing

An Alchemist

Hiring an alchemist will cost a 10d10 GP hiring bonus plus assurance of 300 GP / month for a minimum of 1 year.

Lab/Workshop

Initial outlay for the creation of a workshop costs 200- 1,000 GP, based on the relative availability of the tradesmen and goods necessary to complete the work room and stock it properly (and keep it stocked). In addition, upkeep of the laboratory requires a further monthly outlay of 10% of the total cost of the place, exclusive of any special provisions or protections, in order to stock basic fuel and supplies, replace broken equipment, and so on when the laboratory is in use.

The Appropriate Special Ingredient

There are lists of suggested special ingredients in the DMG (pp. 116-117) and Dragon #130. Per the DMG, there’s no need to figure out what the special ingredient is. Some overly complicated math suggests that the average cost of the special ingredient, if available on the open market, would be 24% of the GP value of the potion. Otherwise, it’d be up to the PCs to acquire.

That said, I really like the idea of specific formula determination as a rate limiter on potion creation. That research would require 1d3+1 weeks at a cost based on the potion’s XP value per week (in addition to any costs for an alchemist), but if the character uses a commune or contact other plane spell to speed his research, they automatically succeed in the minimum time. Otherwise, at the end of this period, successful potion creation requires a roll as per the chance to learn a spell, -2% for each 100 XP (or fraction thereof) of the potion. If the character has a full dose of the potion in question to use as a sample, the research takes one less week with no penalties. If unsuccessful, research continues week-by-week until successful.

Manufacturing

Both the cost in gold pieces and the days of compounding are determined from potion’s XP (default 200 XP otherwise). The XP for a given potion is the cost in GP to concoct the basic formula sans the special ingredient. Each hundred XP (or fraction thereof) indicating one full day of compounding time to manufacture the liquid, i.e., 250 XP = 250 GP basic costs and 3 full days of time. The cost of the special ingredient if available: 24% of GP cost of potion in the DMG.

The DMG suggests: “Alternatively, a 5% to 20% failure percentage can be assigned to all potion manufacture, and those which are failures become delusion potions of the sort which was being attempted, i.e., animal control, flying, etc.” where you either require a special ingredient, or assign a chance of failure.

Where’s the fun in automatic success? So instead, let’s assign that range of failure: 2% for each 100 XP (or fraction thereof). What happens when upon failure to create a potion? The DMG suggests that these failures are simply the source of the potion of delusion, but that’s uninteresting. The Potion Miscibility Table provides some guidance, and can be readily adapted by adapting the wording (see also Dragon #130):

 

Failure

01 EXPLOSION! Those in a 10’ radius take 4-24 hit points, no save.
02-03 A poison gas cloud of 10’ diameter results, and all within it must save versus poison or die.
04-08 Mild poison which causes nausea and loss of 1 point each of strength and dexterity for 5-20 rounds, no saving throw possible.
09-25 Potion ruined and inert.
26-35 Potion at 50% normal efficacy.
36-90 Ruined (potion of delusion).
91-99 Potion has 150% normal efficacy (determine if both effect and duration are permissible, or if only the duration should be extended.).
100 DISCOVERY! The potion’s special formula will cause its effects will be permanent upon the imbiber with potentially harmful side effects.

 

Summary

  • Alchemist: 10-100 GP hiring bonus + 300 GP / month for a year
  • Lab: 200-1000 gp + 10% / month (for a year)
  • Research: d3+1 weeks at XP value / week
  • Manufacturing: Requiring 1 day for each 100 XP (or fraction thereof), at a cost in GP of the XP value, +25% of the GP value of the potion (the special ingredient).
  • Failure: 2% per each 100 XP.

Bibliography

TSR 2011, Dungeon Masters Guide [1e], 1979.
Dragon #2, August 1976. “A new D&D Character Class: The Alchemist”.
Dragon #45, January 1981. “…and one who seems the perfect mix”.

Dragon #49, May 1981. “A recipe for the Alchemist”.
Dragon #130, Feb., 1988. “Better Living Through Alchemy. Poison and Potions: The alchemist NPC class”.
Player’s Option:  Skills & Powers, 1995.
Player’s Option: Spells & Magic, 1996.

Casting About

 

At 10th Level (Master Thief), thieves are able to decipher magical writings and utilize scrolls of all sorts, excluding those of clerical, but not druidic, nature. However, the fact that thieves do not fully comprehend magic means that there is a 25% chance that writings will be misunderstood. Furthermore, magic spells from scrolls can be mispronounced when uttered, so that there is an increasing chance per level of the spell that it will be the reverse of its intent (PHB, p. 27)

I’ve got two thieves approaching level 10—it’s time to refresh myself on thieves casting from scrolls. To translate the above, 10th+ level thieves can read magic user, illusionist, and druidical spells, in addition to the Protection scrolls usable by any class (DMG, p. 128: “Protection scrolls can be read by any class or race of character even without a magic spell”).  While Intelligence can limit spell casting, “Those characters able to read and employ scroll spells may do so regardless of other restrictions” (DMG, p. 128), so the Intelligence of the thief doesn’t limit the level of spells .

The level that rangers and paladins cast a level 1 spell can be a bit confusing (“Does my Level 9 paladin cast Level 1 cleric spells as Level 1, or Level 9?”) but there’s no such question for scrolls. Unless specified otherwise, the scroll will function as a caster 1 level higher than required to cast the spell for the associated class, but at least 6th level (DMG, p. 128). A fireball (Level 3) can be cast as a level 5 magic-user, so will cast as if by a level 6 magic-user (which is also the minimum, i.e., Level 1 and Level 2 magic-user spells will also cast as if by a level 6 magic-user).

So the only thing left is “There is a 25% chance that writings will be misunderstood, and [an increasing chance of a reverse effect].”  We have only one source for chances of magic spell failure:

DMG, pg. 128: Magic Spell Failure: If a spell-user acquires a scroll with a spell(s) of a level(s) not yet usable by the character, the spell-user may still attempt to use the spell; the chance of failure, or other bad effect, is 5% per level difference between the character’s present level and the level of magic use at which the spell could be used. [Any score that represents failure then uses the following table]

Level Difference Total Failure Reverse or Harmful Effect
1-3 95% 5%
4-6 85% 15%
7-9 75% 25%
10-12 65% 35%
13-15 50% 50%
16 and up(a) 30% 70%

(a) Aside: Why isn’t just 16-17? Even assuming 0-level casters, 16-18?

For other spell-users, the chance of magic spell failure is “5% per level difference between the character’s present level and the level of magic use at which the spell could be used”. For the thief, it’s a flat 25% (“there is a 25% chance that writings will be misunderstood “). That makes a strange sort of sense, since the thief doesn’t have a difference in “level of magic use at which the spell could be used” since it’s always Level 10. The implication of Magic Spell Failure is that failure is determined at the time of reading the scroll—the thief won’t know if they will be successful until they attempt to use the scroll. And once they read the scroll to release its magic (successful or not), the writing completely and permanently disappears from the scroll (DMG, p. 128).

But that still leaves the question of how to determine the “increasing chance per level of the spell that it will be the reverse of its intent.” The Magic Spell Failure Table uses the Level Difference to determine the chance of a reverse effect. However, all levels of spell are theoretically accessible by the thief; at 10th level they can utilize “scrolls of all sorts”. Are we back to the paladin/ranger conundrum? However, the thief’s chance of reversal is tied to spell level, not character level. We also don’t consider the thief level for chance of failure—why would we use it for chance of reversal?

Now with no By-the-Book reference, how then to determine the  chance of reversal? The most extreme chance of reversal on the Magic Spell Failure Table is 70%. We can expect that even level 1 spells have a chance of reverse effect for the thief. Using the Magic Spell Failure Table for inspiration, we can come up with several methods to determine the chance of a reverse effect upon failure:

Spell Level Method: Level Difference Actual Reverse Frequency Method: By 5% Actual Reverse Frequency Method: By 10% Actual Reverse Frequency
1 5% 1.25% 5% 1% 10% 3%
2 5% 1.25% 10% 3% 20% 5%
3 5% 1.25% 15% 4% 30% 8%
4 10% 2.50% 20% 5% 40% 10%
5 10% 2.50% 25% 6% 50% 13%
6 10% 2.50% 30% 8% 60% 15%
7 15% 3.75% 35% 9% 70% 18%
8 15% 3.75% 40% 10% 80% 20%
9 15% 3.75% 45% 11% 90% 23%

Actual Reverse Frequency (above) is the calculated likelihood of a reverse effect occurring each time a thief uses a scroll (e.g., 25% chance of failure × 10% chance of reversal = 2.5% chance of the reverse effect occurring). From there we have to consider what was intended. Should a thief have, worst case, a 3.75% chance of a reverse effect when using a 9th level scroll? Probably not. 11% still seems too low. But a 23% total chance of a 9th level spell occurring in reverse seems reasonable, and comes close to maxing out the base chance of spell reversal at 90% (and appropriately worse than the 70% for reverse effect for the Magic Spell Failure Table). That leaves us with the following table:

Thief Spell Failure

Spell Level

Chance of Failure

Chance of Reversal
on Failure

1 25% 10%
2 25% 20%
3 25% 30%
4 25% 40%
5 25% 50%
6 25% 60%
7 25% 70%
8 25% 80%
9 25% 90%

Now that that’s settled (inasmuch as it can be), should the thief be able to cast spells from any spell book? “In extremis, the DM may allow a magic-user to cast a spell directly from any sort of spell book just as if the book were a scroll” (UA, p. 80). The thief can only explicitly “utilize scrolls”, and the ability to cast a spell directly from a spell book is an ability granted to the magic-user “as if it were a scroll”—not that spell books are scrolls. So no.

For assassins, tertiary functions of assassins are the same as thieves, performing thieving at two levels below their assassin level (PHB., p. 29; UA, p. 13). So 12th Level assassin functions the same as a 10th level thief. And, like the thief, their ability to read scrolls never improves.

 

Back Stab By The Numbers

Last Updated: 220204 … 220611 (heavily revised)

Back stabbing is the striking of a blow from behind, be it with club, dagger, or sword. The damage done per hit is twice normal for the weapon used per four experience levels of the thief, i.e. double damage at levels 1-4, triple at 5-8, quadruple at levels 9-12, and quintuple at levels 13-16. Note that striking by surprise from behind also increases the hit probability by 20% (+4 on the thief’s “to hit” die roll).

There’s a lot of uncertainty and misunderstanding about the relative “power” of back stab.  As the thief’s abilities often boil down to back stab, many DMs limit thief abilities. So just how good is back stab, really?

Let’s perform a reasonably direct comparison to the fighter:

  • A fighter, 0 XP, Level 1, Strength 17, THAC0 20 –1 (Str), armed with a long sword (average 4.5 points of damage +1 (Str))
  • A thief, 0 XP, Level 1, Dexterity 17, THAC0 20–4 (back stab), armed with a longsword (average 4.5 points of damage × 2 (back stab)) ). MS: 15%+5% (Dex), HiS: 20% + 5% (Dex).
  • Our generic monster, AC: 5.

Both have a 17 in their Prime ability (Dexterity and Strength respectively), increasing the fighter’s To Hit and Damage, and the thief’s chance to MS and HiS. The thief’s backstab, on average, decreases an opponent’s AC by 1 (no Dex or shield bonus).

In a discussion of THAC0, you have to consider the early repeating 20 in the thief’s to hit chart, and adjust appropriately. A further consideration when comparing classes is relative level for commensurate XP. Generally, a thief should be one level higher than a fighter starting at level 3:

THAC0

Level 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Fighter 19 19 17 17 15 15 13 13 11 11 9 9
Thief (+4)* 15 15 15 15 13 13 13 13 10 10 10 10
T (+4,lvl adjusted)* 15 15 15 13 13 13 13 11 11 11 11 9
* Adjusted for the thief’s 20,20,19 … in the THAC0 chart, Str bonus, Dex benefit lost.

At low levels, the +4 bonus to hit makes a thief more likely to hit than the fighter, but the fighter’s more rapid THAC0 advance overwhelms the +4 bonus by level 7.

Number of Attacks

While the fighter attacks (at least) every round, back stab is limited in frequency. For the thief to back stab, they must approach, back stab, then retreat in order for their opponent to be no longer aware of their presence. Assuming that takes but 2 rounds:

Attacks / Level 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Fighter 1 1 1 1 1 1 3/2 3/2 3/2 3/2 3/2 3/2
Thief .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5 .5

Damage

The thief gains a damage multiplier on back stab, but fewer attacks/round. If we assume both the fighter and thief are using a long sword (average 4.5 hp of damage), then for each hit our fighter does 5.5 hp damage, where the thief using back stab will average 9 damage (levels 1-4), 13.5 damage (levels 5-8), or 18 (levels 9-12).

Putting the Pieces Together

Now, considering our “average” AC:5 monster, that brings us to a simplistic chance to hit per attack of:

Chance to hit AC: 5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Fighter (Str +1) 35% 35% 45%* 45%* 55%* 55%* 65%* 65%* 75%* 75%* 85%* 85%*
T (lvl adj. +4 back) 70% 70% 70% 80% 80% 80% 80% 90% 90% 90% 90% 100%

* Ignoring that our fighter will almost certainly specialize. And again…

Given our fighter also has +1 to damage from strength, the average damage per attack is:

Damage/attack 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Fighter (Str +1) 1.9 1.9 2.5 2.5 3.0 3.0 3.6 3.6 4.1 4.1 4.7 4.7
Thief (lvl. adj w/ mult) 6.3 6.3 6.3 7.2 10.8 10.8 10.8 12.2 16.2 16.2 16.2 18.0
Damage ratio/attack 3.3 3.3 2.5 2.9 3.6 3.6 3.0 3.4 3.9 3.9 3.5 3.9

Or, put another way, the thief’s back stab averages 3.4 times the damage of a fighter hit-for-hit. Not bad! However, while the thief can only (best case) back stab once every two rounds, the fighter’s attacks per round increase, and the thief’s relative chance to hit decreases. A more accurate ratio looks more like:

Damage/round 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Fighter (Str +1) 1.9 1.9 2.5 2.5 3.0 3.0 3.6 3.6 4.1 4.1 4.7 4.7
T (lvl. adj) 3.2 3.2 3.2 3.6 5.4 5.4 5.4 6.1 8.1 8.1 8.1 9.0
Damage/round 1.6 1.6 1.3 1.5 1.8 1.8 1.5 1.7 2.0 2.0 1.7 1.9

Using back stab most generously (every other round), the thief averages 1.7 times damage as a fighter. Nothing earth-shattering—if the thief can back stab every other round, he’s in the ball park of a fighter, but far more vulnerable (AC, HP) once engaged in melee. Hopefully their opponent lets them withdraw. Otherwise the thief remains locked in combat after the initial back stab attempt, with his worse hit points, THAC0 and armor class—not ideal.  Or flee, providing their opponent a +4 bonus in return!

The GM likely requires the thief to move around to their opponent’s back again, for an additional round for the opponent to “lose awareness” (assuming their opponent doesn’t pursue!), bringing that ratio down to 1.1 times the fighter.

Skill Checks

The Level 1 fighter requires a 14 To Hit, so: 35% (TH) * 5.5 Damage (Str) = 1.9 DPR.

Assume the best case: back stab every other round, and no other checks:

Our Level 1 thief requires an 10 To Hit, and: (45% (TH) * 9 Damage (Back stab) ) = 2 DPR.

In other words, back stab DPR looks awesome—better than the fighter! Back stab includes one more consideration—thief abilities. Move Silently is used “to approach to back stab”. Failure means that movement was not silent, and thus back stab fails. The ability to move silently ranges from 10% to 99%, but even a 9th level thief will only succeed 70% (barring race and Dexterity modifiers). That brings our thief back stab / two round damage number down to 50% of the fighter:

Damage/round w/ MS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Fighter (Str +1) 1.9 1.9 2.5 2.5 3.0 3.0 3.6 3.6 4.1 4.1 4.7 4.7
Thief (lvl. adj) 1.1 1.6 1.6 1.8 2.7 2.7 2.7 3.0 4.1 4.1 4.1 4.5
Move Silently (level adj) 0.2 0.3 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.9 1.0
Damage ratio/round 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.8 0.8 0.8 1.0

(For other comparisons, the chance to Hide in Shadows is worse than Move Silently)

In other words, a lot of math later, on a round-by-round basis, the thief, using his premium back stab ability, with back stab every other round, averages 50% of the damage of a fighter. To back stab, he further exposes his poorer AC and hit points to attack. Under the assumption he’s using a long sword, instead of the perhaps more frequent club or dagger.

Multiple Skill Checks:

Some GMs require MS and HiS rolls instead of, or in addition to Surprise. If the GM requires MS (or HiS depending on the GM), we get to the meat of the issue:

Fighter melee DPR (d8) 1.9
Thief back stab DPR 2.03
Thief back stab DPR w/ MS 0.41
Thief back stab DPR w/ HiS 0.30
Thief back stab DPR w/ MS × 2 0.08
Thief back stab DPR w/ His + MS 0.06

With only a single MS check, the fighter averages 429% more damage. Should the GM require two successive checks, the thief’s back stab DPR drops through the floor—the fighter averages 20× more damage than a thief with back stab! If you ask yourself, “Why do my thieves never back stab?”, this would be why.

Surprise

By the Book, Surprise—not MS, not HiS—is required for back stab. Let’s evaluate the thief’s back stab DPR with Surprise. The default chance for Surprise is 2 in 6. A silent thief increases that range to 3 in 6. A silent hidden thief increases that Surprise range to 4 in 6.

“Assume the party of characters, moving silently and invisibly, comes upon a monster. They have 4 of 6 chances to surprise.” PHB, p. 103.

With a generous GM, a thief approaching from behind could be considered invisible (at least hard to see since the thief is by definition at their opponent’s back), receiving the benefit of being hidden after a successful MS.

The Level 1 thief’s back stab DPR under Surprise:

Thief Back stab DPR w/ Surprise (2 in 6) + To Hit 0.60a
Thief Back stab DPR w/ Surprise (w/ MS bonus) (3 in 6) + To Hit 0.76a
Thief Back stab DPR w/ Surprise (w/ MS bonus + auto Hide from rear) (4 in 6) + To Hit 1.07a

aSurprise includes a 16% chance for one attack, a 16% chance for two additional attacks, and (potentially) chances for 3 or even 4 attacks depending on the modified Surprise roll.  Additional back stabs don’t multiply damage, and are only +2 to hit—see Polyhedron #31, p. 29.

If the L1 thief rolls Surprise for a successful back stab, their DPR is .6. If you incorporate a MS check before the Surprise roll to increases the chance of Surprise to 3 in 6, the DPR increases. If you assume that MS includes being hidden (hard to see someone approaching successfully from behind), then their DPR is better yet. Our thief’s DPR is less than that of the fighter, but using Surprise is better than a single MS check.

And the same comparison with our PCs leveled up to the thief’s triple damage? One can quibble about the thief’s speed of advancement for levels, but the levels for the two classes still overlap in this range, so any difference between the two classes is brief.

A thief, 19,000 xp, Level 5, Dexterity 17, THAC0 19 – 4 (back stab). MS: 40%+5% (Dex), HiS: 31% + 5%(Dex), armed with a longsword (average 4.5 points of damage × 3 (Back stab))

A fighter, 19,000 XP,  Level  5, Strength 17, THAC0 16 –1 (Str), armed with a long sword (average 4.5 points of damage +1 (Str))

Here’s all the data in totality:

Prime: 17, Long sword, Opponent AC:5 Level 1 Level 5
Fighter Melee DPR 1.93 3.03
Thief Melee DPR 1.13 1.58
Thief Back stab DPR (only To Hit, no other mods) 2.03 3.71
Thief Back stab DPR w/ MS + To Hit 0.41 1.67
Thief Back stab DPR w/ HiS + To Hit 0.30 1.34
Thief Back stab DPR w/ MS + MS + To Hit 0.08 0.75
Thief Back stab DPR w/ His + MS + To Hit 0.06 0.60
Thief Back stab DPR w/ Surprise (2 in 6) + To Hit 0.60 0.96
Thief Back stab DPR w/ Surprise (w/ MS bonus) (3 in 6)  + To Hit 0.76 1.41
Thief Back stab DPR w/ Surprise (w/ MS bonus+auto Hide from rear) (4 in 6) + To Hit 1.07 2.32

 

Other considerations should you desire more math:

  • A 1e fighter likely has additional bonuses to hit beyond a base 17 Strength. If the campaign uses Specialization, the fighter will have additional bonuses to hit in addition to additional attacks / round.
  • At L6 the fighter’s attacks go to 3/2 without specialization (or 2/1 with specialization), increasing DPR by 50%.
  • If the GM limits the thief to only one back stab every three rounds, all of the thief DPRs decrease 33%.
  • If the attack renders a creature dead, who cares if you compare a back stab 10 hp / round vs 4 hp / round when the creature has only 4 hp?
  • A good argument can be made that Surprise can, at most, provide only 2 additional attacks, as defined as “Surprise” (1 segment) and “Complete Surprise” (2 segments), where the above assumes the possibility of up to 4 segments of Surprise.

The net result is that calculating back stab damage by Surprise has a higher DPR for the thief, yet still considerably less than a fighter of comparable level. Calculating back stab taking more than two rounds, or requiring multiple rolls for success, almost guarantees futility for the thief and back stab.

 

And of course, back stab isn’t always an option. Certain creatures (otyughs, slimes, molds, etc.) either negate surprise or have no definable “back”, thus negating this ability. Back stab isn’t possible against those “aware” of the thief. Depending on the GM, the opponent could be deemed aware after the first attack, so only once per melee. Results swing further when you start to include a more usual fighter to hit/damage bonus from Strength.

UA further lessened back stab with weapon specialization providing fighters a 50% increase in number of attacks (and thus a 50% increase in damage), an increased chance to hit, and a ≥ 20% increase in damage (with at least +1 damage from weapon specialization). And that’s ignoring specializing more than once.

Recommendations

Don’t, just don’t, require multiple skill checks.  Use Surprise, improved by MS (or HiS).

Don’t fear the thief getting to back stab more than once in a fight. The time he spends moving around limits the overall damage per round.

While +4 to hit looks good, over levels it loses value in comparison to the fighter’s THAC0 table. The thief’s bonus to hit should increase at the same rate as the damage multiplier. While you could permit a thief to specialize, that’s not quite the advantage it appears given the thief’s fewer proficiency slots. A flat additional +1 to hit at level 5-8, +2 to hit at levels 9-12 makes back stab scale better, especially if playing with weapon specialization.

While back stab has the occasional wild swing (rolling max damage with a 4× multiplier), the reverse is also true when the high-level thief rolls a “1” for 4 points of damage. Back stab is hard to pull off, and exposes the thief to significantly more peril. If the back stab is successful, a minimum of damage would help offset the risk—a 2-point minimum at level 5, a 3-point minimum at level 9, etc.

What are the Odds? (Paladins)

210501

I had a player who wanted to play a paladin. Rolling up a character via DMG Method IV, we struggled. When looking at the requirements for a paladin per the PHB:
Strength: 12
Int: 9
Wisdom: 13
Con: 9
Charisma: 17

According to the DMG, 1% of the population are classed, and 4.4% of available henchman are paladins. In other words, at a baseline .44% of the population are paladins. Just how hard is it to roll a legal paladin under Method I (3d6), compared to the normal population? What are the odds?

Strength: 12 (37.5%)
Int: 9 (74.1%)
Wisdom: 13 (25.9%)
Con: 9 (74.1%)
Charisma: 17 (1.9%)

Odds for rolling a legal paladin are .1%—one character in every 1,000 could be a paladin using the Method 1: 3d6!

However, at the time, we were using the requirements of the paladin as a subclass of the UA cavalier. Under Method I:
Str: 15 (9.3%)
Int: 10 (62.5%)
Wisdom: 13 (26%)
Dex: 15 (9.3%)
Con: 15 (9.3%)
Charisma: 17 (1.9%)

That _radically_ changes the chances of rolling up a paladin. The odds of rolling up a paladin with the UA requirements using Method I: 3d6? .0002%! That’s two in every million characters rolled up using Method I can be paladins.

Using the more popular Method 2: 4d6, drop lowest (also the method for rolling the aforementioned henchmen), the odds of generating a (valid) paladin are: .03%. Unlikely, and nowhere near the henchman baseline of .44%, but 1 in every 3,333 is still better than 1 in 500,000!

UA of course introduces Method V for rolling up a character, where each individual stat rolls a number of d6 depending on the relevance of that stat to the class. Nine dice are allocated to the most important stat, eight for the second-most-important, etc.  A  paladin would roll 9d6 for Charisma, and drop the lowest six rolls.

Calculating that probability involves formulas that look … insane.  Fortunately, there’s a different way of doing that—brute force.  Out of 10 million dice rolls, for 9d6, the outcomes are:

(0%) 4 -> 7
(0%) 5 -> 48
(0.01%)     6 -> 526
(.02%)     7 -> 2319
(0.07%)  8 -> 7066
(0.24%)  9 -> 23569
(0.63%)  10 -> 63392
(1.39%)   11 -> 138742
(3.01%)   12 -> 311565
(6.01%)   13 -> 600503
(10.30%) 14 -> 1029864
(15.94%) 15 -> 1594458
(22.40%) 16 -> 2240417
(22.06%) 17 -> 2205942
(17.82%) 18 -> 1781582

For the paladin the number of dice are are: 7 5 8 4 6 9 (Note: assuming no Comeliness score). Extending that brute force calculation out, the probability for the required scores for a paladin are:

Str (7d6): 15 (62.09%)
Int (5d6): 10 (92.06%)
Wisdom(8d6) : 13 (91.26%)
Dex (4d6) : 15 (23.15%)
Con (6d6) : 15 (50.92%)
Charisma (9d6) : 17 (39.88%)

Giving us a chance of rolling up a paladin of … .02%

(That doesn’t consider that under UA Method V, the odds of rolling a valid paladin are technically 100%, because if a score is below the minimum requirements, the player takes the minimum for the score).

So what does all of that tell us? Unless you meddle in one way or another with the outcome, paladins should be so vanishingly rare most GMs should see at most one paladin  in their lifetimes:

PHB Paladin, Method 1 (3d6): 1 in 1,000
PHB Paladin, Method 4 (4d6 drop lowest): 1 in every 3,333
UA Paladin, Method 5 (Arcana): 1 in 5,000
UA Paladin (Method I): 1 in 500,000 (see note above)

 

If the world population of paladins is .44% (4.4 in 1000), that also suggests that the party is more likely to encounter a paladin than have one on their own!

  • Looking at DMG Appendix C, 1% of all castles are owned by paladins. 1% of all city encounters are paladins.  2% of the 54% of all human party encounters will include 1-2 paladins.
  • According to the Monster Manual, a band of (uncommon) pilgrims are 35% likely to be Lawful good, there’s a 10% chance there will be 1-10 paladins!

 

The Mathematics Behind 4d6 Drop the Lowest

 

 

 

The Case of Potions for Monks

Last Updated: 201020…211023

I recently had a player, considering playing a monk, ask, “Can monks use potions?” My knee jerk response was, “Of course!” But a closer read proved me wrong.

The text in question:
Magic items usable by monks include all magical varieties of weapons listed (unless proscribed), rings, and those miscellaneous magic items which are usable by thieves. No other magic items of any sort may be employed by monks.

I’d always read that as “all magic items usable by thieves”. But that’s not what it says; it says “all miscellaneous magic items usable by thieves”. Miscellaneous magic item is a category of magic item, just like potions, rings,  Rod/Staff/Wand, etc.

The deeper I dug, the clearer it became. While the text for monks is “those miscellaneous magic items”, the text for the paladin’s magic item limit reads, “any other magic items”. Reviewing Appendix C from the DMG, all characters encountered in a city/town may possess one or more magic items. In the table for item determination, monks are assigned no chance of having a potion. They do have a chance of having a misc. weapon, a protection device, a ring, or misc. magic, just like the PHB description. That table explicitly breaks out “Misc. Magic” as a category.

Appendix P provides a method for creating an adventuring party. On the Potions Table the monk is not listed as having a chance to have a potion (nor scroll on the Scroll Table), but the monk could have a magic weapon or miscellaneous item (and again Miscellaneous Item is broken out as a category).

Appendix P is, almost word-for-word, the “Putting Together a Party on the Spur of the Moment” article by Gary Gygax, published in Dragon #26, June, 1979 and the unquestionable  precursor to Appendix P: Creating a Party on the Spur of the Moment. The article includes an almost identical “Potions Table” as Appendix P—identical except that the Dragon article assigns the monk a 4% chance/level of having a potion. The monk’s chance was removed from the table as part of revisions for the DMG!

The Ghost Tower of Iverness (C2), one of the early tournament modules, permits the PCs to shop for magic items before the adventure. “Rings, weapons, and miscellaneous items usable by thieves are the only
items the monk may use.”  And again, Miscellaneous Items is broken out as a separate category.

Going deeper still, monks were originally introduced in the Original D&D Blackmoor supplement. The quote there?

Monks have no magical abilities per se. Besides magical weaponry, monks may only use rings and those miscellaneous magic items usable by thieves. Potions and scrolls may not be used.

I don’t have electronic (searchable) copies of all the 1e  modules. The Mad Hatter (monk) in EX1? No potions. T Diumm and T. Deeous (monks) in EX2? No potions. Eson the Wise (I7)? No potions. Urquant (UK2)? No potions.  Sion & Hadley (UK4)? You, you guessed it. By random determination, there’s a 20% chance of the magic item you have being a potion.

One module includes an exception—the two monks in C1, who used a unique item (the potion of dreadful sleep) to enhance their ability to feign death. Modules aren’t perfect sources for canonical information, as the authors often change the rules to wrap a module to their intent. In this case, for example, the authors have this one potion affect the NPC monks in a different manner than normal for the potion—extending their feign death. C1 also includes numerous changes or expansions to core rules: changes to slow poison and neutralize poison; adding a barbarian’s ability to detect poison; non-thieves able to attempt move silently, etc., etc.  This one exception in C1 hardly provides enough strength to ignore the other examples.

By the Book, the description is clear enough, and it’s backed up by substantial circumstantial evidence. Monks can’t use potions.

They can in my campaign anyway. How about yours?